Power does not change people; rather, it alters what they choose to hear. As power grows, the desire to hear flattering words increases, while the willingness to hear uncomfortable truths diminishes. Eventually, leaders may find themselves unknowingly trapped in an 'echo chamber,' a space where their thoughts are merely repeated back to them. This term emerged in the era of democracy, but the underlying issue was recognized by political thinkers in China over 2,000 years ago.
Han Feizi, a prominent figure in Chinese Legalism, warned that the greatest threat to a ruler is not the enemy but the sycophantic minister. Since a ruler cannot verify all information personally, they rely on reports from their subordinates. When these reports are tailored to please the ruler's mood, governance is built on illusion rather than reality. Han Feizi cautioned that when a ruler only hears what they want to hear, the state is destined for decline. History has repeatedly proven this point.
One of the most revered emperors of the Tang Dynasty, Emperor Taizong, had a minister named Wei Zheng, who boldly told the emperor, 'Your Majesty, that is a mistaken judgment.' He often criticized the emperor so openly that it sometimes embarrassed Taizong, who would become angry. However, once his anger subsided, Taizong would reflect on Wei Zheng's words. After Wei Zheng's death, Taizong lamented, 'If I use a bronze mirror, I can correct my attire; if I use a historical mirror, I can understand the rise and fall of states; if I use a person as a mirror, I can recognize my own mistakes. Now that Wei Zheng is gone, I have lost a mirror.' This illustrates that a leader's most valuable asset is not a loyal follower but someone who speaks the truth.
Today, this phenomenon is referred to as an echo chamber in politics. People tend to gather around those in power, but not everyone is a trusted advisor. Many are individuals seeking positions, promotions, nominations, business opportunities, or expanded networks. They have little reason to upset the powerful. Consequently, frank advice disappears, leaving only applause.
Initially, this change is subtle. Phrases like 'You are doing well,' 'The public is pleased,' and 'There is no need for concern' become repetitive. As these affirmations accumulate, leaders begin to trust reports over reality and their inner circle over public sentiment. At that moment, the echo chamber is complete.
Politics is not confined to boardrooms. It exists in press rooms, market alleys, and social gatherings. Veteran politicians value these spaces because they contain unrefined public sentiment.
Journalists can sometimes serve as the most uncomfortable mirrors for politicians. Through journalists, politicians can see a world they might otherwise miss. Similarly, long-time friends, rivals, and even critics are necessary mirrors for leaders. As power strengthens, leaders need more mirrors to reflect reality.
This principle applies globally. In 1961, the Kennedy administration in the United States faced a catastrophic failure with the Bay of Pigs invasion. Most advisors aligned with the president's views, and dissenting opinions were not adequately voiced. To avoid repeating this mistake, Kennedy changed his approach to meetings. During the Cuban Missile Crisis, he intentionally sought out opposing views and engaged in extensive discussions, which ultimately helped the world step back from the brink of nuclear war.
Contrary to popular belief, dissenting opinions do not weaken power; they can actually prolong it. This holds true in democracies as well. Winning an election does not equate to winning the hearts of the public. High approval ratings are not permanent. Politics is an ongoing process of interpreting shifting public sentiment. There is no guarantee that yesterday's supporters will make the same choice today.
Therefore, leaders must constantly examine their surroundings. While politicians should look to the sky and articulate their vision, they must also keep their feet firmly on the ground. They need to continually assess where their feet are planted and in which direction public sentiment is moving. If there is no one nearby to inform them of this reality, leaders are living in a world of their own making rather than the actual world.
The decline of power often begins not with a strong enemy but at the moment a leader closes their ears. Thus, leaders should surround themselves with those who offer frank advice rather than yes-men. The public does not seek a perfect leader; they desire a leader who can first acknowledge their own mistakes. The courage to break free from the echo chamber is a leader's ultimate competitive edge.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.