Gunfire erupted in the Strait of Hormuz just days after the ink dried on a ceasefire agreement between the United States and Iran. Less than ten days after signing a memorandum of understanding (MOU), attacks on commercial vessels and retaliatory airstrikes, along with missile and drone counterattacks, unfolded. While it seemed the war had paused, the embers of conflict remained alive, as tensions reignited by exploiting gaps in the agreement.
This latest clash highlights both the successes and limitations of President Donald Trump’s foreign policy. Trump’s strategy, which emphasized military power, sanctions, and overt threats, successfully brought Iran to the negotiating table. The agreement was significant, especially as fatigue over prolonged conflict grew and the blockade of the Strait of Hormuz threatened global energy markets.
However, bringing parties to the negotiation table is different from managing the aftermath of an agreement. The MOU left many critical issues, such as the method for Iran’s nuclear disarmament, the scope of sanctions relief, and the management of the Strait of Hormuz, to be addressed in future negotiations. Notably, the phrasing regarding discussions between Iran and Oman about the future management of the strait allowed for differing interpretations: Iran viewed it as a justification for expanding control, while the U.S. saw it as a starting point for restoring freedom of navigation.
Ambiguity can sometimes be necessary in diplomacy, especially when it is impossible to resolve all issues at once. However, the problem arises when there are no mechanisms in place to manage that ambiguity. This is particularly true following an agreement made immediately after gunfire and missile exchanges. Without a framework to reconcile differing interpretations, the language of the agreement could become a pretext for future clashes rather than a foundation for peace.
Iran also bears responsibility in this situation. It appears to be using the ceasefire agreement as an opportunity to expand its control over the Strait of Hormuz. Threats and attacks on commercial vessels disrupt international shipping norms, and retaliatory actions targeting U.S. military bases in the Gulf only escalate the risk of broader conflict. As Iran leverages the Strait of Hormuz as a negotiating tool, instability in the Middle East could once again pose a risk to the global economy.
Yet, the U.S. cannot resolve the issue solely through stronger airstrikes and harsh rhetoric. Trump has warned that a time may come when military action against Iran is necessary, suggesting that Iran would cease to exist if that were to happen. However, such threats may temporarily pressure Iran but will not resolve the underlying conflict over control of the strait. In fact, they could strengthen hardline sentiments within Iran.
What is needed now is not a complete abandonment of the logic of power. The U.S. cannot ignore attacks on commercial vessels, nor can it refrain from responding to actions that threaten international shipping routes. However, military deterrence is effective only when paired with a clear diplomatic framework. It must be established what constitutes a violation, what procedures will be activated in the event of a violation, and who will monitor and guarantee safe passage through the strait. Otherwise, the cycle of airstrikes, retaliation, warnings, and further retaliation will only continue.
Future negotiations must clarify the principles governing the management of the Strait of Hormuz alongside the Iranian nuclear issue. This cannot be left solely to Iran and Oman. A monitoring and coordination mechanism involving the U.S., Gulf states, major energy-importing nations, and the international shipping industry is essential. The processes for sanctions relief, strait stability, and nuclear negotiations must be linked and clearly defined for violations. Only then can the MOU function as a minimal safety net rather than a mere piece of paper.
Trump’s logic of power played a role in halting the war. However, the renewed military confrontations in Hormuz demonstrate that this approach alone cannot maintain peace. Ending a war does not automatically bring about peace. If the U.S. seeks genuine diplomatic success, it must move toward more comprehensive agreements rather than relying solely on threats. A war halted by force cannot be sustained by force alone.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.