Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix stocks have been experiencing significant fluctuations, often rising sharply after declines of 3% to 5%. The KOSPI index is also reacting to the movements of these two companies, leaving individual investors struggling to determine their investment direction. Amid this volatility, analysts are presenting starkly contrasting price targets for both stocks, further confusing investors. The disparity in SK Hynix's price target among brokerages has reached as high as 3.22 million won.
According to the Korea Exchange, on October 21, Samsung Electronics closed at 223,500 won, up 5.67% from the previous trading day, while SK Hynix finished at 1,294,000 won, a 5.81% increase. The surge in these large-cap stocks contributed to a rise of 182.93 points (3.29%) in the KOSPI, which closed at 5,735.67.
The stock prices of both companies have been increasingly volatile. Although prices surged on this day, Samsung Electronics fell by 4.13% and SK Hynix by 6.81% the day before, on October 20. In October alone, Samsung Electronics has dropped 19.0%, while SK Hynix has seen a decline of 29.4%, with both stocks experiencing swings of over 3% on seven trading days.
The outlook for these stocks varies widely among analysts. According to financial information provider FnGuide, 15 brokerages have issued price targets for Samsung Electronics this month, with SK Securities setting the highest at 610,000 won and BNK Investment & Securities the lowest at 270,000 won. For SK Hynix, among the six brokerages providing targets, IBK Investment & Securities and SK Securities both set the highest at 4 million won, while Mirae Asset Securities set the lowest at 3.1 million won. The price target gap for Samsung Electronics is 340,000 won, while for SK Hynix, it is 900,000 won.
When considering previous reports, the gap in price targets widens further. BNK Investment & Securities has set the lowest targets at 270,000 won for Samsung Electronics and 1.48 million won for SK Hynix. In contrast, Korea Investment & Securities has set the highest targets at 650,000 won and 4.7 million won, respectively. This results in a price target difference of 380,000 won for Samsung Electronics and 3.22 million won for SK Hynix.
The divergence in stock price forecasts stems from differing analyses regarding the duration of the memory boom and supply-demand dynamics. Optimistic forecasts suggest that increased investment in artificial intelligence (AI) infrastructure will sustain demand for high-bandwidth memory (HBM) and enterprise solid-state drives (eSSD) for an extended period. Nomura Securities predicts that memory demand will exceed supply at least until 2028, maintaining price targets of 670,000 won for Samsung Electronics and 4.7 million won for SK Hynix.
Conversely, pessimistic views argue that rising memory prices could dampen demand. BNK Investment & Securities suggests that major tech companies, facing increased costs, may reduce the memory capacity in new products as part of cost-cutting measures, potentially leading to a slowdown in demand growth for IT products and servers. Coupled with aggressive capacity expansions by producers, there are concerns that the market could shift to oversupply after the second half of next year.
The widening gap in price targets is exacerbating confusion among investors. A financial industry insider noted, "Profit forecasts and methods for calculating price targets can vary significantly among brokerages. In a highly volatile market, it may be more beneficial for investors to focus on understanding the overall market situation rather than placing excessive emphasis on price targets."
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.