Two Security Firms Fined 970 Million Won for Bid Rigging in Apartment Contracts

Fair Trade Commission building in Sejong City
Fair Trade Commission building in Sejong City. [Photo by Yoo Dae-gil]
Approximately two years of collusion between S1 and S-Tech Systems in 23 integrated security service bids for private apartments in Busan, Gwangju, and four other regions has been uncovered by the Fair Trade Commission (FTC).

On July 5, the FTC announced that it has imposed corrective orders and a total fine of 970 million won on S1 and S-Tech Systems for agreeing in advance on the winning bidder and bid prices.

The collusion occurred from November 2022 to January 2023 across 23 private apartment complexes in six regions, including Busan, Gwangju, Daejeon, Sejong, South Chungcheong, and North Chungcheong.

S1 solicited bids for security services at apartments where it had previously conducted business, while S-Tech Systems participated as a dummy bidder. Although S1 expected to have an advantage in the proposal evaluation, it requested S-Tech Systems to participate in the bidding to avoid situations where bids would fail or be rejected.

Before the bidding, the two companies agreed that S1 would be the winning bidder and that S-Tech Systems would participate as a dummy. They also coordinated bid prices when necessary. As a result, S1 won 21 out of the 23 bids or secured contracts after failed bids, with only two contracts awarded to a third-party company.

In effect, over 90% of the bids subject to collusion resulted in contracts with S1. The repeated participation of the dummy bidder limited actual competition, despite the appearance of a competitive bidding process.

S-Tech Systems had little experience in providing integrated security services in the six regions, making it difficult to consider it a genuine competitor to S1. The FTC noted that the long-standing cooperative relationship following S-Tech Systems' spin-off from S1 contributed to the collusion.

Integrated security services combine mechanical security, such as closed-circuit television monitoring and access control systems, with manpower. Only companies that meet specific requirements regarding security personnel, capital, facilities, and equipment and have received approval from the local police can participate in the bidding.

The FTC deemed the collusion a serious violation of laws that restricted competition in security service bids funded by apartment residents' management fees. It imposed fines of 641 million won on S1 and 332 million won on S-Tech Systems, with the final amounts subject to adjustment.

An FTC official stated, "We have significantly raised the minimum fines and criteria for penalties related to bid rigging and other unfair joint actions. We plan to take stricter measures if similar violations are detected in the future."




* This article has been translated by AI.