Direct Financial Support for Loss-Making Companies: Key Considerations

The need for direct financial support for loss-making companies that cannot immediately benefit from production tax credits is growing, alongside calls for a more sophisticated post-management system. Experts argue that support should not be solely based on whether a company is in the red, but should also consider the company's potential for recovery and its importance in national strategic industries.


According to a report released by the Bank of Korea on November 8, which analyzed the status of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and suggested improvements to support systems, enhancing the criteria for selecting beneficiaries and improving restructuring efficiency could increase total production by approximately 0.4% to 0.7%, even without increasing the support budget. Notably, if the criteria for support were shifted from sales to years in operation, it is estimated that total production could rise by 0.45% as funds would be redistributed to more productive, younger companies.


This model analysis underscores the importance of efficiency in the selection and method of support, as much as the scale of support itself. The Bank of Korea recommends that support should focus on productivity and innovation capabilities rather than just the size of a company's sales or assets, and that tailored support should be strengthened according to the growth stage of the business.


The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) also highlighted the need for improvements to tax credit systems to enhance their effectiveness while managing fiscal burdens in its investment tax guide released in April. Loss-making companies or newly established firms may not fully utilize tax credit benefits due to insufficient tax liabilities. However, it also suggested limiting refund eligibility or setting refund caps by business type to consider fiscal constraints.


In South Korea, a key challenge in expanding direct support will be distinguishing between companies facing temporary management difficulties and those that have structurally lost competitiveness. The mere fact of recording a loss does not automatically justify the need for financial support. It is essential to assess whether a company can normalize production and investment through funding or if it is unlikely to recover profitability even with additional support.


Another critical criterion is whether the industry is a strategic sector that needs to maintain its production base at the national level. This involves considering not only the company's profitability but also its significance within domestic production facilities and supply chains, as well as the broader industrial impact of any production stoppage.


The method of support should also vary according to the circumstances of the companies. For firms with high recovery potential but currently lacking liquidity, subsidies or policy financing may be necessary. For companies needing to pivot their business, support could be linked to facility investments and technology development.


Internationally, there are efforts to enhance the cashability of tax credits to improve support effectiveness. In the United States, the Inflation Reduction Act allows direct payments and transfer of credits for companies meeting certain criteria related to advanced manufacturing tax credits. Canada offers refundable tax credits for up to 30% of eligible capital investments in clean technology manufacturing.


However, it is crucial to ensure that rapid financial support does not lead to wasteful spending. There is a need to monitor investment, employment, and production outcomes after support is provided. Criteria should be established to halt or reclaim support from companies that fail to meet initial goals. Regular performance evaluations of supported companies and a reassessment of the sustainability of their operations are also necessary.


Park Hoon, a professor of taxation at the University of Seoul, emphasized the importance of determining whether a company's losses are a temporary phenomenon and whether financial support can aid in recovery. He noted that the strategic industries or future growth drivers that the state needs to maintain should also be key criteria in this assessment.





* This article has been translated by AI.