Restrictions on Public Disclosure by Serious Crimes Investigation Agency Raise Questions


The Serious Crimes Investigation Agency (SCIA) has explained its policy restricting the public disclosure of names of high-ranking officials and corporate representatives as a measure to protect human rights during investigations. However, questions remain regarding the criteria for disclosure, especially when compared to other agencies that allow exceptions for pre-indictment disclosures.

On November 10, the SCIA responded to media reports about its policy limiting the disclosure of names, stating that the differences arise from the distinct stages of criminal procedures between the Prosecutor's Office and the SCIA. They noted that disclosing suspect facts before an indictment could lead to legal issues under the Criminal Code regarding the public disclosure of suspect facts.

Previously, the Chosun Ilbo reported that the SCIA's regulations on public relations for investigation cases, which took effect on October 29, include a principle of anonymity for involved parties but lack a specific provision allowing for the disclosure of names of public figures. The report indicated that the reasons for disclosure are narrower than those outlined in the Ministry of Justice's public relations regulations, focusing on preventing the spread of crime victimization, apprehending suspects, ensuring public safety, and responding to misinformation.

The roles of the Prosecutor's Office and the SCIA differ significantly. The Prosecutor's Office decides whether to indict cases referred to it and maintains prosecutions, while the SCIA is responsible for confirming criminal allegations and gathering evidence. Given that disclosing ongoing investigation details could influence evidence destruction or witness testimonies, it is challenging to uniformly compare the disclosure scopes of the two agencies.

Nonetheless, the SCIA's investigations involve significant public oversight. The SCIA Act mandates investigations not only into serious crimes such as corruption and economic offenses but also into crimes committed by public officials affiliated with the Prosecutor's Office, police, Anti-Corruption Agency, and the judiciary. In cases involving influential figures or public authority, concerns about excessive investigations and delays or reductions in investigations also come into play. An overly broad scope of non-disclosure could restrict access to information necessary for such oversight.

The Ministry of Justice's regulations on public relations for criminal cases do not only apply post-indictment. Article 2 states that these regulations apply from the moment a prosecutor receives a case for review regarding indictment, while Article 9 outlines exceptional disclosure criteria before indictment. Article 12 allows for the disclosure of names of public figures or individuals whose names are already widely known, contingent upon necessity and approval from the relevant prosecutor.

The Anti-Corruption Agency (ACA) serves as a comparable example in terms of investigation stages. The ACA generally prohibits disclosures before investigations conclude, but Article 8 of its public relations guidelines allows for the release of information regarding case reception, investigation initiation, subjects, key suspect facts, and charges, provided it is approved by the Public Relations Review Committee in response to public interest or media requests. This procedure is separate from misinformation responses. For certain high-ranking officials, exceptions for disclosing names and specific positions are also permitted following review.

In fact, the ACA held a briefing on January 23, 2024, when it referred a case involving then-President Yoon Suk Yeol to the prosecution, explaining the reasons for the referral and the progress of the investigation while disclosing the president's name. This instance illustrates that disclosures can occur before an indictment, even considering the ACA's partial indictment authority.

There have also been instances where the ACA differentiated the scope of disclosures during investigations. In a regular briefing in March 2024, the ACA stated that additional questioning of former Defense Minister Lee Jong-seop was necessary but refrained from confirming specific details such as phone replacements or the destruction of work notebooks. This indicates a distinction between explaining investigative policies and disclosing individual pieces of evidence or testimonies.

The SCIA has indicated that it can respond to media inquiries for fact verification. In its announcement, it emphasized that it has provisions to disclose necessary information if misinformation or speculative reporting is anticipated.

However, there are concerns that merely correcting misinformation through public relations does not fulfill the accountability owed to the public regarding significant cases. Even in the absence of erroneous reporting, there may be a need to explain why major cases are unresolved or take a long time to conclude. This highlights the necessity for investigative agencies to have a channel to inform the public about how they exercise their authority, regardless of the real-name disclosure issue.

Given the nature of agencies dealing with corruption, economic crimes, and offenses by public officials, there is ongoing criticism regarding the need for public oversight of the investigation processes and outcomes.

Article 126 of the Criminal Code stipulates that individuals performing investigative duties who disclose suspect facts before indictment can face penalties. The Supreme Court has also stated that the public interest, necessity, accuracy, procedures, and manner of expression must be comprehensively assessed when considering disclosures by investigative agencies.

The key issue surrounding the SCIA's public relations policy is not simply whether to increase or decrease disclosures. It is essential to prevent the spread of unverified allegations while ensuring that serious crime investigations are conducted appropriately.




* This article has been translated by AI.