Army Veterans Lose Korean Citizenship, Highlighting Multicultural Family Issues

President Lee Jae-myung stated on October 30 that "administrative fairness is a core value of the state, and fairness is unrelated to the quantity of benefits." He emphasized that support for multicultural families aims to ensure equality by addressing discriminatory elements against native citizens, suggesting that some multicultural families receive excessive privileges. His comments have sparked heated social debate regarding the 'preferential treatment system for multicultural families.'


However, while the government applies its standards of fairness, the cries of 'second-generation multicultural' individuals are echoing from the administrative blind spots. They have lost even the most basic right of 'nationality' that they should enjoy as citizens of South Korea. Critics point out that while the state imposes obligations such as military service and taxes, it has erased the legal status of multicultural families, creating another form of injustice. The reality of multicultural youths, who have lived as South Korean citizens for decades only to suddenly become 'legal ghosts,' starkly illustrates the shadows of the 'fairness' that President Lee emphasized.


‘Administrative fairness is a core value of the state.’

Nam Jeong-hyeon (pseudonym), a 23-year-old from a multicultural family, describes himself as a 'ghost' after completing his mandatory service in the Army, living in fear of deportation.


‘Fairness is unrelated to the quantity of benefits.’

Kim Dong-jun (pseudonym), a 22-year-old from a multicultural family, fell into statelessness while preparing to enter the Air Force Academy.


‘Even small amounts should not be unfair.’

Park Jin-ki (pseudonym), 37, married to a Russian woman, received a notice from the government demanding repayment of 2 million won for health insurance reimbursements his 3-year-old son received over three years.


This is a real situation occurring in South Korea. Such incidents, which should be unacceptable even for a single citizen, are happening to second-generation multicultural individuals. All three have lived their lives as Koreans, only to discover one day that they or their families are not legally recognized as South Korean citizens. For nearly 20 years, they received no guidance or warnings from the government. Instead of receiving assistance, they fear being penalized and hide their situations, living exposed to various disadvantages. Let’s follow their stories.


◆ Second-generation multicultural individuals turned into legal ghosts… ‘Obligations’ imposed by the state

Nam Jeong-hyeon, residing in Suwon, Gyeonggi Province, expressed that he feels like a 'ghost.' He lives in fear of being labeled an 'illegal resident' by the state and facing disadvantages in his livelihood. He is a 'reserve' who completed his military service last year. During his 18 months in the military, he was a young man full of dreams about his future in college and work. However, what awaited him upon returning to society was the shocking revelation that he had lost his South Korean nationality 20 years ago.


Born in South Korea in 2004, Nam received a birth certificate and completed his official birth registration at the local administrative welfare center. He was assigned a resident registration number, completed public education, and paid health insurance and various taxes. He underwent a physical examination and served in the military under the identity granted by the state. He stated, “I was born and raised in Korea, and for over 20 years, I received no guidance or sanctions from the government. I never imagined such a thing could happen after serving in the military. I was truly shocked.”


The cause was 'dual nationality.' Nam's mother, originally from Russia, acquired Russian nationality for him when he was young. The Ministry of Justice deemed this process as 'voluntary acquisition of foreign nationality' under Article 15, Paragraph 1 of the Nationality Act, which states that “a person who voluntarily acquires foreign nationality shall lose their South Korean nationality at the time of acquisition.”


Nam criticized, “If I were a foreigner, the state would have sent a conscription notice to enlist me in the military. The administrative system has neglected its citizens. If it imposes obligations, it must guarantee their identity and rights. This is a clear administrative violation and legal contradiction.” He expressed concern that unresolved nationality issues could restrict his long-term employment and financial activities, stating, “All my important life plans have been thrown off track. I can’t even visit my family in Russia for fear of my status becoming an issue.”


The tragedy faced by Lena (pseudonym), 54, is similar. Married to a South Korean man for over 30 years, she has two sons and a daughter. Her second son hoped to enter a public school during high school and renounced his Russian nationality after taking the college entrance exam. While waiting for her turn at the Ministry of Justice, Lena was shocked to hear that her son no longer had South Korean nationality. “My son was standing right next to me, and I couldn’t fathom how much of a shock it would be for him,” she recalled, her eyes welling with tears.


In an instant, her son became a 'stateless person,' lacking both Russian and South Korean nationality. This occurred despite his pride in being 'Korean' and his decision to enlist voluntarily. He even faced whispers from officials who were unaware of the details, questioning whether he was trying to avoid military service. Lena recalled, “It was a moment filled with fear that my son could be deported at any moment.”


Her son had to endure with a temporary foreign resident permit. The first noticeable impact was medical expenses. After visiting a hospital for a skin treatment he usually received, he was hit with a bill of 900,000 won due to the cancellation of his health insurance coverage, despite his father consistently paying health insurance premiums.


Three months later, her son regained his nationality. He is currently serving in KATUSA (Korean Augmentation to the United States Army). However, his resident registration still shows a record of 'loss of nationality,' which hinders his job prospects as a young adult.


Park Jin-ki, residing in Uiwang, Gyeonggi Province, learned at the Ministry of Justice last year that his 3-year-old son had already lost his nationality. Park had also intended to acquire Russian nationality for his newborn son, which became problematic.


To regain his son's nationality, Park renounced his Russian nationality and formally applied for nationality recovery. Shortly after, he received a sudden bill for 2 million won, demanding repayment for health insurance reimbursements his son had received. This meant he had enjoyed benefits as a non-national and was required to return the amount.


Moreover, he was excluded from government support for public daycare centers. When a child with South Korean nationality uses a public daycare center, the government covers 100% of the childcare fees, leaving parents with no out-of-pocket expenses. However, Park's son was deemed not to be South Korean, forcing him to pay 270,000 won monthly for four months, totaling 1 million won.


Park expressed frustration, saying, “I have been paying taxes and engaging in economic activities as a South Korean citizen. The government should have resolved this issue with just one document review, yet instead, they came with legal grounds saying, ‘You are an illegal person, pay up.’ How can an ordinary citizen know specific legal provisions? I was really angry.”


He even confirmed with the government multiple times when applying for Russian nationality, ensuring there would be no issues with his son's South Korean nationality. He received assurances from the Ministry of Justice's foreign affairs center that acquiring his mother's nationality would not affect his South Korean nationality.


Realizing the seriousness of the issue, Park postponed work to resolve his son's situation but ultimately had to pay the full amount demanded by the government. The notice that late payments would incur monthly penalties added to his stress. He remarked, “The state did not know about the loss of my nationality until I personally applied for recovery, and only then did they realize and demand money. If they had notified me in advance that there was a problem, or provided guidance, this issue would not have arisen.”


◆ “I want my nationality back for my child”… The ‘loss of nationality’ boomerang

This issue stems from the unique circumstances faced by second-generation multicultural individuals. Those born in South Korea to multicultural families are often stigmatized as 'foreigners' by the state without realizing the administrative errors occurring between their 'father's country' and 'mother's country.' Ultimately, these youths are left abandoned by the state, losing even the minimum rights of citizenship, living in fear of forced deportation and economic burdens.


Russia adopts a principle of 'jus sanguinis,' granting nationality based on the nationality of the parents. To grant Russian nationality to a child born in South Korea, parents must notify the Russian consulate and apply. Parents viewed this as a natural administrative act to register their children according to diplomatic needs or domestic laws.


However, South Korea's nationality law stipulates that acquiring foreign nationality results in the automatic loss of South Korean nationality. The primary reason for this is military service. Given the unique situation of being a country in a state of armistice, the law aims to maintain fairness in military obligations, prevent conflicts of loyalty and national security, and avoid 'cherry-picking' where individuals enjoy rights while neglecting obligations.


The problem is that individuals like Nam, who have already completed military service, or Lena's son, who hopes to enlist, are nonetheless marked for loss of nationality without exception. Victims argue that the current nationality law, which is outdated, has led to repeated injustices for second-generation multicultural individuals.


◆ Taxed and enlisted as ‘citizens,’ labeled ‘foreigners’ upon losing nationality… The state’s negligence and misinformation

Victims strongly criticize the state’s 'administrative convenience' and shifting of responsibility. While they are treated as full South Korean citizens when issued resident registration numbers and subjected to tax and military obligations, they received no prior warnings or individual notifications regarding foreign nationality connections or loss of nationality.


In particular, according to victim groups, many parents received incorrect information when inquiring at the Ministry of Justice's foreign affairs center before registering their children's dual nationality, being told that “if they report nationality selection before the age of 22 and pledge not to exercise foreign nationality, they can maintain both nationalities.”


Attorney Kang Seok-jun noted, “There are recorded instances of calls where parents were informed they could maintain dual nationality.” He pointed out that the core issue is whether the state can view the registration of dual nationality for minor children, based on the trust in the state’s public guidance, as 'voluntary acquisition' of South Korean nationality, and whether the principle of trust protection should be upheld for citizens who relied on the state’s guidance.


However, the Ministry of Justice has remained silent in response to the victims' appeals. Yulia, who is active as a representative of the victim group seeking solutions for the dual nationality issues of second-generation multicultural families, stated, “We have formally requested the Ministry of Justice to take a position and provide measures regarding the situation of second-generation multicultural individuals becoming stateless, but we have yet to receive any response.”


◆ A blind spot where the situation remains unrecognized… Multicultural families pushed to the brink

Even more concerning is that government agencies, including the Ministry of Justice, have not even gathered official statistics on the affected individuals. The investigative team at Aju Economy confirmed at least 38 households through victim groups and related law firms.


Many individuals live without even knowing that they have lost their South Korean nationality, while others, aware of the situation, hide their identities due to fear of repercussions. The potential victims are impossible to estimate.


Victims describe this issue as a 'ticking time bomb' that could spread to more multicultural families. According to the Ministry of Justice's 'Statistics on Foreigners Entering and Residing,' as of last year, there were 2,682 households of Russian marriage immigrants residing in South Korea. Including those from countries like the UK, Australia, Vietnam, and Kazakhstan, which also adopt the principle of 'jus sanguinis,' there are over 46,000 households living in South Korea.


During the months it takes to process nationality recovery, individuals must endure as temporary foreign residents. This directly impacts their education, employment, and adds economic burdens such as health insurance reimbursement claims. Particularly vulnerable multicultural families, especially those with disabled family members or living in public rental housing after divorce, face threats to their very survival as housing and welfare support are cut off along with the loss of nationality.


◆ “Retroactive application needed to erase the stigma of nationality loss”

In July, a bill was introduced in the National Assembly to amend the nationality law, recognizing individuals who acquired foreign nationality during their minority as dual nationals rather than losing their nationality. However, the proposed retroactive relief provisions for those who have already lost their nationality were not included. The amendment has been pending for four months.


Experts emphasize that 'restoration of status' is crucial for multicultural youths who have lived their lives believing they are South Korean citizens. Professor Janna Balrod of Seongkyunkwan University's Global Business Department stated, “If confusion surrounding nationality processing continues, children from multicultural families may face suspicion regarding their nationality from public institutions. The psychological scars and identity confusion individuals may experience, especially teenagers and young adults, could impact their education and career paths.”


She added, “The current nationality law amendment must include provisions for retroactive relief for those who have already lost their nationality, and the government should consider urgent measures to temporarily suspend disadvantageous actions such as health insurance reimbursement claims.”


A Ministry of Justice official stated, “The acquisition of foreign nationality occurs for personal reasons, so without the individual's voluntary report, it is difficult for the state to know about the loss of nationality. Until the individual reports their loss of nationality, they may appear to maintain their status as citizens.”


He added, “We are providing support for children of international marriage families who lose their South Korean nationality by granting them overseas Korean (F-4) or resident (F-2) status to facilitate stable domestic residence. We are also implementing measures to process nationality recovery applications quickly within one month and to exempt fines and penalties.”


Regarding the incorrect guidance provided by the foreign affairs center, the official explained, “It is presumed that consultations and guidance were conducted based on the principles for congenital dual nationals,” and regarding the inclusion of retroactive provisions in the nationality law amendment, he stated, “It is necessary to carefully consider the impact on established legal relationships when uniformly restoring nationality that has already been lost.”


The Ministry of Gender Equality and Family stated, “We are comprehensively analyzing the overall evaluation of support policies for multicultural families, including this issue, and identifying areas needing improvement, such as discrimination, in collaboration with relevant ministries. We will include this case in our review of improvement measures.”





* This article has been translated by AI.