What the Emperor Has to Do: Insights on Housing Policy


Recently, as prices for Gangnam apartments began to decline, President Yoon Suk Yeol has increased his social media messages. He stated, "The actual transaction prices in major areas of Seoul are dropping remarkably, and there are concerns about a crash," and emphasized, "It is important to provide accurate real estate data to the public." In response to reports indicating that home prices have risen outside of Gangnam, he argued that he only explained the prices in the three districts of Gangnam and never claimed that prices in all of Seoul are crashing. Citizens observing the president's frequent social media responses feel fatigued. While the president's messages should resonate with the public, the surrounding reactions suggest otherwise.

It is necessary to examine whether the president's social media messages align with the actual market situation. It is true that the actual transaction prices for high-end apartments in Gangnam, such as Apgujeong and Banpo, have fallen. The Shin Hyun-dae apartment in Apgujeong, which sold for 12.8 billion won last December, recently traded for 9.2 billion won, a drop of 28%. However, in November 2024, it was valued at 8.4 billion won, and in December 2023, at 6.27 billion won. Over two years, it increased by 200% and then fell by about 30% within a year. Not all apartments in Gangnam have seen significant declines, and some complexes have recorded recent increases in transactions.

Interpreting the increase in listings and decrease in transactions as signs of a crash should also be approached with caution. The number of apartment listings in Seoul rose from around 57,000 at the beginning of the year to 77,000 by March due to the expiration of the transfer tax exemption. After the tax was implemented, it dropped to 60,000 but increased to 80,000 following tax reforms. This is still lower than the 87,000 listings recorded in May of the previous year, before President Yoon took office. The increase in listings can be viewed as a result of high-end apartment owners choosing to sell during the grace period rather than a spread of panic.

The volume of apartment transactions in Seoul also fell to around 3,000 for three consecutive months from August to October. This decline was influenced by severe regulatory burdens and a drop in stock prices. The designation of land transaction permission zones prevented purchases with jeonse (key money) and effectively blocked loans, while high-end apartment buyers faced pressure from tax audits. Additionally, the stock market's decline has tightened financial resources, making it difficult for transactions to increase. While stock prices fall when listings increase and transactions decrease, this principle does not apply to apartments. Unlike Gangnam, where falling listings are often for tax evasion, Gangbuk has many listings at rising prices. Even with a decrease in transactions, a single reported high-price transaction can indicate an increase.

The president's emphasis on the accuracy of statistics also warrants attention. In October, the price change rate for apartments in Gangnam was reported as -1.38% by the Korea Real Estate Agency, -0.29% by KB Real Estate, and +0.03% by Real Estate 114, reflecting discrepancies among reporting agencies. These differences arise from variations in sampling and survey methods. The differing sampling methods of the Korea Real Estate Agency and KB Real Estate likely account for the varying degrees to which declines in some high-end apartments in Gangnam are reflected in the statistics.

The current situation brings to mind Hans Christian Andersen's tale of 'The Emperor's New Clothes,' where the emperor believes he is well-dressed despite being naked. To discuss the stabilization of Gangnam's housing prices, at least three years of observation is necessary. If stability continues until the end of the term, it will not be too late to discuss the success of policies then. During the Roh Moo-hyun administration in 2003, strong regulations led to stabilized housing prices in 2004, prompting the relevant department to celebrate with champagne and awards, but memories of prices soaring again from 2005 onward remain vivid.

If a parent punishes a teenager for frequently meeting friends and not improving grades by shaving their head and taking away their allowance, the child may avoid friends and stay in their room temporarily. However, this does not mean the child has learned a lesson. Just as it is essential to create an environment conducive to studying and to wait, it is crucial to steadily supply housing while restoring market confidence. High-end apartments in Gangnam are far removed from the lives of ordinary citizens. It is vital to consistently supply apartments in Seoul's Gangbuk, Gyeonggi, and Incheon areas, which are important for the housing stability of ordinary citizens.

The key to developing new cities in the metropolitan area is speed and transportation. Budget allocations should ensure early subway openings coincide with the new city occupancy dates. Given the limitations of public supply, easing regulations to increase private supply is also necessary. The repeal of the excess profit recovery from reconstruction and the prohibition of transferring membership rights should be considered, and even if the mandatory holding period is extended, the registration rental business system should be revived. Regulations that hinder construction companies from engaging in rental businesses also need to be addressed. Even with incentives, few construction companies are willing to enter the rental market under heavy taxation. The absence of construction rental projects by the representative construction rental company, Booyoung, in Seoul is also due to regulations. To stabilize the rental market, it is essential to quickly increase the supply of rental units.




* This article has been translated by AI.