Controversy Arises Over Funding for Lee Jae-myung's Rural Basic Income Plan

President Lee Jae-myung's signature campaign promise of a 'rural basic income' is being funded by reallocating budgets from existing welfare programs for the elderly and youth. Critics argue that reducing funds from established welfare initiatives to provide a new monthly payment of 150,000 won to residents is akin to 'robbing Peter to pay Paul.' The National Assembly Budget Office has also raised concerns about the potential replacement of existing welfare programs and the financial burden on local governments. Despite these warnings, the Lee administration plans to expand the pilot program from 17 counties to around 35 before evaluating its effectiveness.


According to the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs and the National Assembly Budget Office, the total budget for the rural basic income pilot program in 2026 is approximately 751.02 billion won. The national government will cover 300.47 billion won (40%), while local governments will bear 450.62 billion won (60%).


The largest local government contribution comes from Okcheon County in North Chungcheong Province, which will allocate 26.06 billion won. Following are Yeoncheon County in Gyeonggi Province with 24.04 billion won, Sinan County in South Jeolla Province with 21.51 billion won, and Namhae County in South Gyeongsang Province with 20.72 billion won. These regions have very weak financial foundations, with Okcheon County's fiscal independence at just 10.2%, Yeoncheon at 13.1%, Sinan at 6.8%, and Namhae at 8.6% based on the 2026 budget.


A significant issue is that funding for the rural basic income is being sourced from cuts to existing welfare budgets. A case in point is Jangsu County in North Jeolla Province. According to exclusive documents obtained by the investigative team at Aju Economy, Jangsu County has adjusted six resident support projects to free up 1.45 billion won for the rural basic income. This includes 881 million won for elderly beauty care, 230 million won for vulnerable groups' bathing expenses, 197 million won for youth vouchers, and 79 million won for hygiene products for young women. Additional funds include 50 million won for support for new residents and 15 million won for assistance to those acquiring citizenship.


In essence, while the government claims it is expanding welfare, it is actually reducing existing welfare budgets for the elderly and vulnerable populations to fund the new initiative.


For the 2026-2027 rural basic income funding of 22.6 billion won, Jangsu County plans to utilize 12.6 billion won from increased grants, 3.9 billion won from stabilization funds, 2.7 billion won from the local extinction response fund, 2 billion won from surplus funds, and 1.4 billion won from expenditure restructuring. Notably, the stabilization fund is money set aside for financial emergencies, and expenditure restructuring involves cutting or adjusting existing project budgets. This raises concerns that the implementation of the president's promised initiative may sacrifice local financial capacity and existing resident support programs.


Other regions are also adjusting budgets to fund the rural basic income. Muju County plans to cover 7.71 billion won from its integrated financial stabilization fund and 6.99 billion won from surplus funds, which together account for 76.2% of its total funding plan of 19.3 billion won. Jeongseon County will use 10.2 billion won from Kangwon Land dividends and 7.41 billion won from surplus funds. Boseong County in South Jeolla Province has also indicated it will utilize its integrated financial stabilization fund.


The Budget Office has already warned about the financial burden and the potential replacement of welfare programs. In its analysis of the 2027 budget proposal released on October 30, it pointed out that expanding the rural basic income could increase the financial burden on local governments and replace essential welfare programs or budgets for vulnerable groups.


The Budget Office predicts that the number of people eligible for the rural basic income will surge from 521,000 this year to 1.29 million next year, a 2.48-fold increase. Even if the government raises its funding share from 40% to 50%, the financial burden on local governments is expected to increase by about 2.07 times. This suggests that the demand for funding may exceed the benefits of reduced local burden due to the increased number of recipients.


In particular, the Budget Office warns that if substantial local funds are allocated to the basic income in a context of limited financial capacity, budgets for existing welfare programs such as elderly care, child welfare, and low-income support could be reduced. If existing support programs are replaced by the basic income, there is a risk that the overall welfare level for residents could effectively decline.


Concerns have also been raised about the timing of the program's expansion. The rural basic income is intended as a pilot program to evaluate its effects and side effects from 2026 to 2027. The government initially planned to assess the impact on population influx and local economic revitalization before deciding on a full rollout. However, it is now looking to expand participation to over half of the 69 rural counties facing population decline, with 34 counties applying for the new round of funding that closed on November 4. The government plans to select around 18 additional counties.


The Budget Office has cautioned that rapidly increasing the number of participating regions before adequately verifying the program's effectiveness raises questions about the validity of the pilot program's evaluation. There are concerns about expanding the program's scale before confirming its contributions to population influx, settlement, and local consumption.


The government's explanations have also fueled controversy. On December 3, the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs stated that local governments are adjusting priorities and optimizing projects to secure funding, considering the importance and urgency of the initiative.


However, the actual budget adjustments in Jangsu County illustrate how the government's notion of 'project optimization' may impact resident support programs. If existing support is reduced or consolidated to fund the basic income, it is essential to consider both the new payment of 150,000 won and the reductions in previously provided benefits. Simply increasing the payment does not necessarily equate to an increase in residents' overall welfare.


During last year's presidential campaign, Lee promised to provide rural residents with cash payments in the form of local currency to stimulate local consumption and the economy. Since taking office, the government has been pursuing this as a national agenda. However, the effectiveness of the policy should be judged not just by the fulfillment of the promise but by the actual improvement in residents' living standards and the local economy.


Experts argue that the absorption of existing welfare budgets by the rural basic income was a predictable outcome, necessitating a more strategic policy review. Seok Jae-eun, a professor of social welfare at Hallym University, stated, "The rural basic income lacks clear objectives. While cash support may yield short-term population growth or economic revitalization effects, these are expected outcomes with limited sustainability. If temporary population increases and economic growth are interpreted as the pure policy effects of the basic income, there is a risk of overestimating its positive impact. Japan has implemented similar living security measures in areas facing population decline, but these were ultimately deemed ineffective. It is crucial to evaluate whether policies that prioritize survival over self-sufficiency are appropriate long-term solutions for population decline or balanced regional development."


Seok further emphasized that given the limited resources of local governments, the rural basic income will inevitably absorb existing welfare benefits. He urged that residents should be properly informed about the disappearance of previously utilized welfare programs before the policy is implemented and that evaluations should consider changes in welfare benefits for individuals or groups.





* This article has been translated by AI.