AVI Opposes Dowoo Technology's Investment in JoongAng Ilbo


Dowoo Technology's approximately 2.2% stake is managed by the UK-based investment firm Asset Value Investors (AVI), which has issued an open letter opposing Dowoo Technology's acquisition of new shares in JoongAng Ilbo. AVI has requested the board to reconsider the investment, citing insufficient justification for the acquisition price and investment profitability.

On November 16, AVI stated in its open letter that the decision to invest in JoongAng Ilbo could harm shareholder value and requested an official response from the board by November 30.

Previously, on November 4, Dowoo Technology announced its decision to acquire 38 million common shares of JoongAng Ilbo for 190 billion won. This acquisition will be conducted through a third-party allocation of new shares, resulting in a post-acquisition stake of 34.36%. The acquisition is scheduled for December 23, with the company citing business diversification and synergy creation as the investment's purpose.

The total scale of new share acquisition by the consortium, which includes Dowoo Technology, Saramin, and CJ, amounts to 520 billion won. AVI sent a private letter to Dowoo Technology's board on October 21, expressing concerns about the investment. Although it received a response on October 30, AVI stated that the core issues were not adequately addressed, prompting it to escalate its concerns into a public issue.

AVI raised several concerns, including the appropriateness of the acquisition price, expected returns from the investment, and the potential for an expanded discount rate on the stock. AVI argued that given JoongAng Ilbo's profitability and financial condition, a detailed rationale for the acquisition price must be provided. It specifically requested an explanation for why the consortium's acquisition amount exceeds the previously reported competitive bid range of 300 billion to 400 billion won.

Additionally, AVI called for transparency regarding the valuation methods and key assumptions used by Dowoo Technology, as well as the expected share value, anticipated return rates, and investment recovery periods post-acquisition. AVI also questioned the business relevance of the investment, stating that the newspaper business has low direct correlation with Dowoo Technology's existing financial IT, messaging, and groupware operations, making it difficult to justify that diversification alone would enhance shareholder value.

AVI emphasized the need to consider the responsibilities and potential additional financial burdens associated with joint management, especially given regulations limiting ownership stakes by large corporate groups in the newspaper sector.

AVI also addressed the issue of Dowoo Technology's undervalued stock. According to AVI's estimates, as of October 30, Dowoo Technology's stock was trading at approximately a 62% discount to its net asset value (NAV). AVI argued that the investment in JoongAng Ilbo could complicate Dowoo Technology's governance structure and potentially widen the discount on its stock due to concerns about future capital injections.

As an alternative, AVI proposed a share buyback and cancellation strategy. It explained that based on the current discount rate, investing 1,000 won in a share buyback would effectively cancel shares equivalent to an estimated net asset value of about 2,630 won.

AVI has demanded that Dowoo Technology's board disclose the rationale for the acquisition price, the results of financial and legal due diligence, and the reviews conducted by independent directors. Furthermore, it requested the establishment of a special committee composed of independent directors, supported by external experts, to reassess the transaction terms and decision-making process.




* This article has been translated by AI.