The Supreme Court will deliver its first judicial ruling on whether the December 3 martial law constitutes a rebellion under criminal law during the appeal of former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo.
According to legal sources on November 16, the Supreme Court's full bench, led by Justice Oh Kyung-mi, has scheduled the ruling for Han's appeal on November 19 at 4 p.m.
Initially, November 19 was set only for the second full bench hearing of Han and former Minister of the Interior and Safety Lee Sang-min's cases, but the Supreme Court has decided to issue a ruling on the same day, which is unusual.
This scheduling is seen as a measure considering the expiration of Han's detention period, which is set to end on November 20. Han has been in custody since January after being sentenced in the first trial, with his detention period extended three times at the Supreme Court level (on May 21, July 21, and September 21).
There has been speculation in political circles that delays in the Supreme Court's proceedings could lead to Han's release due to the expiration of his detention, raising questions about judicial accountability. The ruling Democratic Party of Korea initially mentioned the impeachment of Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae but later shifted its stance to pursue a national investigation amid concerns of backlash.
Noh Kyung-pil, head of the Court Administration Office, testified at an emergency inquiry by the National Assembly's Legislative and Judiciary Committee, stating, "We have made every effort to complete the hearings within the detention period, and the ruling draft is nearly complete, which is why the ruling date has been set."
He added, "The fundamental issue causing this situation (regarding Han's detention) is that our country uniquely has restrictions on detention periods, and I hope this can be resolved legislatively."
This ruling is expected to have significant implications as it will be the Supreme Court's first conclusion before the appeal ruling for former President Yoon Suk-yeol, who faces charges of rebellion and was sentenced to life imprisonment in the first trial, with his appeal ruling scheduled for January 26.
The Supreme Court will determine whether the declaration of martial law on December 3 and the deployment of troops to the National Assembly and the National Election Commission meet the legal criteria for rebellion as defined in Article 87 of the Criminal Code, which requires a purpose of disrupting the constitutional order and acts of insurrection.
Han is accused of attempting to create the appearance that the declaration of martial law was legally conducted by suggesting a Cabinet meeting and seeking signatures from Cabinet members after the declaration.
In the first trial, the court classified the martial law as a rebellion and sentenced Han to 23 years in prison, which was heavier than the prosecution's recommendation. The second trial upheld the conviction for rebellion but reduced the sentence to 15 years, acquitting him of some perjury charges.
The key issue highlighted by the full bench is the interpretation and application of the crime of rebellion. However, Han's defense has consistently argued that he was unaware of the martial law declaration in advance and did not support it.
The Supreme Court's ruling on whether Han's actions surrounding the martial law declaration can be considered significant duties related to rebellion is expected to be a crucial factor in determining the outcomes of the trials for Lee and former Justice Minister Park Sung-jae, whose detention periods are also set to expire next month.
The full bench, led by Justice Park Young-jae, will also rule on Kim Geon-hee's appeal at 4 p.m. on the same day.
Kim has been indicted for her involvement in stock manipulation related to Deutsche Motors, receiving illegal funds from the Unification Church, and accepting a public opinion survey worth 270 million won from political broker Myung-tae Kyun. She was sentenced to 1 year and 8 months in the first trial and 4 years in the second trial, along with a fine of 50 million won.
A key issue in these cases is whether the provision of the public opinion survey can be considered an illegal political donation under the Political Funds Act.
Meanwhile, the ruling on the appeal of former President Yoon, who testified as a witness in Han's rebellion trial and was indicted for perjury after being acquitted in both the first and second trials, is scheduled for the morning of November 26.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.