The Democratic Party's special counsel law for manipulated prosecutions passed the Cabinet meeting on November 17. While it claims to clarify suspicions raised about the investigation and prosecution processes of the Yoon Suk Yeol administration's prosecution, the bill is fraught with constitutional controversies and legal contradictions. Moreover, the inclusion of cases related to President Lee Jae-myung in the investigation raises doubts about the independence and fairness of the special counsel. Given the bill's significance, the Cabinet meeting should have involved thorough review and discussion, but the process was questionable as it was handled during the Prime Minister's meeting while the president was abroad.
The Cabinet meeting is not merely a formal procedure for endorsing government legislation and policies. The constitutional responsibility assigned to Cabinet members is to filter out the potential unconstitutionality and illegality of bills, as well as their policy side effects. Particularly for a special counsel law that could shake the foundations of the national criminal justice system, stricter scrutiny is essential. However, this bill passed through the government's final decision-making process without sufficient explanation of key issues or social discussion. One must question whether the Cabinet meeting fulfilled its role as a constitutional check.
The most concerning aspect is Article 26 of the special counsel law. This provision allows for reduced or waived sentences for those who provide important statements or testimonies regarding another person's crime. While it may be seen as encouraging cooperation in investigations, it could effectively induce testimonies in a specific direction and provide incentives for retracting statements, leading to serious side effects. Above all, determining the responsibility and evidence for specific cases to set sentences is the exclusive authority of the courts. If legislation attempts to effectively bind the courts' sentencing judgments, it poses a significant risk of conflicting with the constitutional independence of the judiciary.
The structure for recommending and appointing special counsel candidates is also not free from fairness controversies. Although the president makes the final appointment from candidates recommended by both ruling and opposition parties, the inclusion of cases related to the president himself in the investigation raises doubts about the neutrality of the exercise of appointment authority. The rule of law values not only conducting fair investigations but also securing public trust that investigations are fair. If the special counsel deals with cases where the president has a vested interest, the composition and appointment process must adhere to much stricter standards of independence.
From the perspective of consistency in prosecution reform, the situation is contradictory. The Democratic Party has been reforming the criminal justice system by reducing the prosecution's direct investigative powers. However, this special counsel law effectively revives investigative authority for prosecutors dispatched to the special counsel. If the focus is on addressing the concentration of prosecutorial power and exceptions are made only for specific special counsels, it raises questions about the principles of reform. Even individuals within the ruling coalition have publicly expressed concerns about the law's investigative effectiveness and potential unconstitutionality, which should not be taken lightly.
If there were issues with past prosecutorial investigations, they must be thoroughly clarified, and accountability must be enforced. However, this process must not give rise to another political investigation controversy or undermine the independence of the judiciary. The special counsel should be a means to uncover suspicions, not a shield for specific political forces. The Cabinet's decision does not guarantee the legitimacy of the bill. Even now, the government and ruling party must sincerely address the constitutional issues raised and establish measures to ensure the independence and fairness of the law. Creating laws favorable to power is not reform; upholding principles that may be unfavorable to power is true rule of law.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.