Proof of Humanity Through the Wear of Exam Books

“You see a page in a magazine featuring a full-body nude photo of a girl. Your husband likes the photo very much and hangs it on the bedroom wall. What would you do?”

 
This is one of the many questions posed in the 1982 film 'Blade Runner' to distinguish between the replicants and humans. The test determines whether someone is human not by the content of their answers but by measuring the tremor of their pupils in response to the questions. It is a classic test from the 1980s.
  44 years later, a strikingly opposite scene unfolds. This year, the runner-up of the tax accountant exam revealed the worn exam book he studied from in front of a camera, showing evidence of his efforts, and even solved problems on the spot. It was a moment that emphasized he passed the exam purely through his own abilities without the help of artificial intelligence (AI).
 
This video was released on YouTube around the time suspicions were swirling that the top scorer in the same exam may have cheated using AI. Ultimately, the top scorer of the 2026 tax accountant exam admitted on the 15th that he had committed fraud using a miniature camera and generative AI.

In the film, the questions were directed at the replicants. The questioner was human, while the one trying not to be discovered was the replicant. However, now, 40 years later, it is humans who are being tested. Following the confession of cheating by the top scorer, those who passed various qualification exams in recent years may have to spend their lives justifying that they did not use AI.
 
The higher the score, the more suspicion it attracts, and evidence of how one studied must be left behind. One must create a worn exam book and retain login records from online lectures. In this world, those who studied honestly must desperately prove their humanity.
 
The original novel 'Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?' by Philip K. Dick, which inspired 'Blade Runner,' contains a setting that seems to foresee the current turmoil.
 
In the book, Earth is covered in radioactive dust after a nuclear war, with only a few humans surviving, and most plants and animals nearly extinct. In such a situation, raising a living animal is not only a sign of wealth and social status but also a proof of human empathy.
 
However, when the protagonist Deckard's real sheep dies, he is left raising an 'electric sheep,' a fake sheep disguised as a real one. Deckard is always anxious that the true identity of the fake sheep will be revealed.
 
Thus, the top scorer who has been exposed for cheating could be called an electric sheep. Hidden within a score that appears to be genuine was a machine. However, while Deckard's dilemma was about making the fake appear real, the dilemma in our society now is how to show that the real is indeed real.
 
As I ponder how to prove the real, I arrive at a more uncomfortable question: If AI can achieve near-perfect scores on the tax accountant exam, is there really a need for human tax accountants?
 
Amid this tax accountant exam controversy, a lawyer with tax accountant qualifications and a former National Tax Service investigator reportedly solved 15 out of 40 questions on the same exam, scoring 37.5 points. This raises a broader societal question: “Is it better to leave tax matters to AI?”
 
Let’s return to the question from 'Blade Runner.' It is important to remember that the test distinguishing humans from replicants did not ask about knowledge. There is no correct answer to the question of what to do about a husband who likes nude photos. What this test measured was not the rate of correct answers but the magnitude of emotional disturbance.
 
Memorizing tax laws and performing calculations is now an area where AI surpasses humans. Therefore, shouldn’t the criteria for qualifying exams that determine this profession change? It may be time to redefine what should be measured in exams: the ability to understand and properly assess the circumstances and situations of clients, which lies within the unique human domain.
 
This year’s college entrance exam must create a testing environment that everyone can recognize as a genuine human, countering the ever-advancing technology. The moment the credibility of that test is questioned, tens of thousands, if not millions, of examinees may bear the burden of proving their authenticity for a lifetime.
 
In 'Blade Runner,' Rachel was subjected to over 100 questions before her identity was revealed in a test that typically identifies humans in about 20 or 30 questions. How many questions will current examinees have to answer to be recognized as human? It is an era where one must prove their humanity through the wear of their exam books instead of the tremor of their pupils. It is a bitter reality, but at least AI cannot replicate the wear of human hands.



* This article has been translated by AI.