Special Counsel Notifies Kim Wan-seop of Deferred Prosecution Without Indictment


The second special counsel team, led by Kwon Chang-young, has recently revealed that it notified former Minister of Environment Kim Wan-seop of a deferred prosecution regarding allegations of budget diversion for the presidential office relocation, without formally indicting him. In the trial concerning the 12·3 state of emergency case, the court raised questions about the basis for considering boarding the 'martial law bus' as participation in insurrection and the timing of the announcement of the state of emergency declaration.

According to legal sources on the 17th, the special counsel informed Kim, who was the head of the budget office at the Ministry of Strategy and Finance during the office relocation, of the deferred prosecution on August 20 and communicated the same to the media. Deferred prosecution is a decision made by prosecutors acknowledging the charges but opting not to proceed to trial due to various considerations.

Kim's legal team, which denies the allegations, prepared a constitutional appeal and requested a non-indictment disposition, only to receive a response from the special counsel stating that there had been no formal indictment.

The special counsel investigated allegations that approximately 2.8 billion won (KRW) from the Ministry of the Interior and Safety's budget was illegally diverted to pay for the presidential office relocation construction costs in 2022. Kim was listed as a witness in a search warrant on June 8. When coordinating his appearance, he was informed that he was a 'suspect witness,' but during the investigation on June 26, the special counsel prepared a suspect interrogation record on charges of abuse of authority.

A special counsel official involved in the investigation at the time stated that Kim was investigated as a substantial suspect and that they considered the burden of requiring him to reappear for formal indictment in a situation where they decided not to proceed with charges. Kim's side pointed out that they spent time and resources preparing for an appeal due to incorrect notifications.

In the trial concerning the state of emergency case, the court requested the special counsel team to specifically explain which actions of the defendant were considered as participation in insurrection.

The 37th Criminal Division of the Seoul Central District Court (Presiding Judge Ryu Chang-seong) questioned the reasons for indicting Kim Sang-hwan, the former head of the Army Headquarters Policy Office, among those who boarded the 'martial law bus,' and asked for the basis of how boarding the bus led to participation in the state of emergency. While scheduling witness testimonies on the 16th, the court also requested that the evidence plan be supplemented with relevance to the case.

In the case of Jeon Ha-kyu, the former spokesperson for the Ministry of National Defense, the indictment was amended. The special counsel submitted a statement indicating the timing when Jeon contacted the presidential office and other entities to announce the state of emergency declaration to the National Defense reporters. When the court pointed out that the charges themselves needed to be amended, the special counsel requested changes in court, which the court approved.

In the case of Shin Yong-hae, the former head of the Ministry of Justice's Correctional Headquarters, there were concerns raised about the sequence of events related to checking the capacity of detention facilities in the metropolitan area. After confirming the supplementary statement and evidence plan provided by the special counsel on the 16th, the court decided to begin witness testimonies starting from December 3. The first witness will be Park Sung-jae, the former Minister of Justice, who is identified as having directed Shin to check the detention capacity.

Meanwhile, on the 17th, the special counsel sought a one-year prison sentence during the sentencing hearing for Hong Chang-sik, the former legal officer of the Ministry of National Defense, for dereliction of duty. The ruling is scheduled for 2 PM on December 22.

The special counsel argued that Hong failed to advise the Minister and Vice Minister of National Defense on the requirements for martial law or the necessity of troop withdrawal, despite having received relevant case law a month before the state of emergency.




* This article has been translated by AI.