Lee Jae-myung's Rural Basic Income Pilot Program Faces Funding Challenges

As President Lee Jae-myung pushes for the expansion of the Rural Basic Income pilot program, participating local governments are struggling to sustain the initiative due to excessive financial burdens and are calling for increased national funding. The government has announced plans to raise the national funding rate to 50% next year, but Gurye County in South Jeolla Province has requested that the national funding rate be increased to 60% starting in 2028. This raises concerns about the sustainability of the program as local governments implement it.


A Gurye County official explained to our reporter, "Our county is providing an additional basic income of 50,000 won (KRW) per person from our own budget. However, the 150,000 won (KRW) set by the government is itself a burden. Additional support through increased national funding is necessary."


On November 16, the investigative reporting team of Aju Economy reported that the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs stated, "We will increase the national funding rate next year to alleviate the financial burden on local governments." The ministry also mentioned to our reporter, "There have been no complaints or requests to withdraw from participating local governments. Positive feedback about the program has been reported in the target areas." However, contrary to the ministry's explanation, Gurye County has officially stated that it is difficult to continue the program due to financial burdens.


Despite planning to spend 60.8 billion won (KRW) next year, Gurye County's funding request cites 'non-existence'


According to a proposal obtained exclusively by Aju Economy's investigative team regarding the transition to the main Rural Basic Income project and the request for increased national funding, Gurye County stated that the background for the request is "the uncertainty of transitioning to the main project and excessive local financial burden (47.5%), which limits sustainable implementation." The county also pointed out that the uncertainty regarding the transition to the main project could undermine policy credibility and negatively impact the continuous settlement of population inflow.


Consequently, Gurye County has demanded that the government "present a roadmap for the implementation of the main project to secure predictability and credibility of the policy." The county has requested that the national funding rate be gradually increased from the current 40% to 50% in 2027 and 60% in 2028, and that the funding structure be changed to 60% national funding, 20% provincial funding, and 20% local funding.


The proposal also calls for a separate system to secure stable funding. It includes a statement suggesting the establishment of a basic income account within the special account for local finance or the consideration of creating a separate fund. This indicates that the existing local financial management methods are insufficient to sustain the project over the long term, and a national-level funding procurement system is needed.


The budget Gurye County proposed for next year is also substantial. The county stated, "Of the 608 billion won (KRW) required for 2027, 28.9 billion won (KRW) will be covered by local funds (182 billion won (KRW) from national funding and 13.7 billion won (KRW) from provincial funding)." This estimate is based on the existing funding structure of 40% national funding, 30% provincial funding, and 30% local funding. The county emphasized to the government that it must bear 28.9 billion won (KRW) of the total 608 billion won (KRW) budget.


Gurye County provides a monthly payment of 200,000 won (KRW) to residents by adding 50,000 won (KRW) from its own budget to the government's basic payment of 150,000 won (KRW). As of this year, the basic payment of 150,000 won (KRW) is shared as 40% national funding, 30% provincial funding, and 30% local funding. The additional payment is fully covered by local funds. Consequently, of the 200,000 won (KRW) paid to residents, 95,000 won (KRW) is borne by local funds, accounting for 47.5% of the total payment.


Next year, while the increase in national funding will reduce the local burden rate, the necessary budget remains significant. According to Gurye County's expenditure budget statement for 2027, the basic income project cost, applying the conditions of a 50% national funding rate and payments for 25,318 residents over 12 months, amounts to 60.76 billion won (KRW). This includes 22.79 billion won (KRW) from national funding, 11.39 billion won (KRW) from provincial funding, and 26.58 billion won (KRW) from local funding. This amount does not include separate operational costs for the project.


Notably, there is a reversal of the burden between national and local funding. Even if the government raises the national funding rate to 50% for the basic payment, Gurye County will have to bear 3.8 billion won (KRW) more than the national funding. Based on the total monthly payment of 200,000 won (KRW), the national funding rate is 37.5%, while the local funding rate is 43.75%.


The bigger issue is the specificity of funding procurement.


In response to a request from Aju Economy's investigative team for details on the funding sources for securing local funding for basic income and budget adjustment materials for other projects, Gurye County replied that all such information "does not exist." They only stated that more than 26.5 billion won (KRW) in local funding will be needed next year, but they have remained silent on how this funding will be secured.


There also appears to be a lack of concrete evidence regarding the evaluation of the Rural Basic Income program. The proposal states, "After the pilot project implementation, the policy effects such as income stabilization and population increase (2.6%) have become visible." However, no comparison dates or methods for calculating the population growth rate have been provided. It has not been verified whether the actual increase in the settled population is due to the basic income payments. Simply attributing population growth to the success of the basic income policy lacks substantiation. In this regard, Professor Seok Jae-eun from Hallym University’s Department of Social Welfare pointed out, "Temporary population growth or economic revitalization following the implementation of basic income is expected, so emphasizing this as an effect is not very meaningful. If the policy is expanded nationwide, there is a high possibility that the expected effects will not continue."


It is noteworthy that Gurye County Mayor Jang Gil-seon, affiliated with the Democratic Party, made a key campaign promise during the June 3 local elections to provide a basic income of 300,000 won (KRW) to all residents. Recently, concerns were raised in the Gurye County Council that if the payment were set at 300,000 won (KRW), the local funding burden would increase to approximately 64.7 billion won (KRW) annually, potentially depleting the financial stabilization fund. While the election promised to expand the basic income program, which is a signature policy of President Lee Jae-myung, the proposal submitted by Gurye County to the central government states that even the current payment of 200,000 won (KRW) is "limited in sustainability due to excessive local funding burden (47.5%)." This raises criticism that a feasible financial plan should have been presented before promoting the scale of the promise.


◆Despite addressing six support projects for the elderly and vulnerable, the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs claims 'efficiency' without verifying beneficiary impacts.


The Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs stated in its explanatory materials that local governments are securing funding by utilizing revenues from renewable energy and local festivals or by adjusting their income and expenditure plans. Regarding the adjustments made by Jangsu County to six existing resident support projects, the ministry explained, "Some have been consolidated with similar projects, and some have been restructured for operation." Although adjustments were made to the existing support projects for elderly beauty and vulnerable group bathing fees, it was also stated that related facilities can be freely accessed through basic income.


However, the mere fact that beauty and bathing services can be used at local love gift certificate merchants does not explain the impact of the adjustments to existing support projects on residents. The ministry has not presented how much the elderly and vulnerable groups, who were previously the targets of existing projects, have utilized related services after the basic income payments were introduced, nor how the conditions for utilization have changed due to the restructuring of support methods. Moreover, there are concerns that the shift from targeted welfare, which was previously concentrated on vulnerable groups, to cash support dilutes the intent of local welfare to provide robust protection for the vulnerable.


The Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs also reaffirmed its plan to raise the national funding rate from 40% to 50% next year, thereby reducing the provincial and local funding rates by 5 percentage points each. They stated that they would consider the financial conditions of local governments and the means of securing local funding when selecting participating regions. However, these adjustments apply only to the national funding for the basic income project and do not address the additional payments that participating local governments, such as Gurye County, must bear.


Furthermore, the ministry stated in the same explanatory materials that it would analyze the impact of basic income on local finances and its economic and social outcomes in the future. They plan to compare regions that implement the program with those that do not and evaluate changes in residents' quality of life and local economic conditions. This means that a comprehensive evaluation of the financial impact and policy effects of the project has not yet been completed.


The National Assembly Budget Office also pointed out in its analysis of the 2027 budget proposal released on the 30th of last month that caution should be exercised in expanding the project’s target before the evaluation of the Rural Basic Income program's performance is completed. They warned that the financial burden on local governments may increase, potentially replacing existing welfare projects and budgets for vulnerable groups.


However, President Lee stated during a National Assembly address on December 2 that the target regions for the Rural Basic Income program would be doubled to 35 counties. The government plans to select around 18 new counties in addition to the current 17. This indicates a move to expand the scale of implementation before verifying the results of the pilot project.


Gurye County's proposal illustrates that merely raising the national funding rate will not resolve the financial burden issues faced by local governments. Since Gurye County has independently decided on the additional payments, the responsibility for the scale of the project and funding procurement also lies with local governments. However, the central government, which is pushing for nationwide project expansion, must also verify the financial capacity and ongoing burden potential of each region.


Professor Song Kwang-tae, an emeritus professor of public administration at Changwon National University, stated, "If the basic income project is expanded without thorough verification, it could impose irreversible burdens on local finances. Even with national funding, local budgets will continue to be required, leading to significant financial pressure on rural areas with very low financial independence. Welfare projects, once implemented, cannot be reversed. Therefore, caution is necessary in implementing and expanding such projects. It is essential to determine whether the region can survive without basic income and what the exact expected effects of basic income are."





* This article has been translated by AI.