[Exclusive] 'Smart Glasses' Monitoring Network Launched, But Tax Accountant's Use of 'Mini Camera' Goes Unchecked

The cheating incident involving the top scorer in this year's 63rd Tax Accountant Qualification Exam has been identified as a structural blind spot in the management system of national qualification exams, unable to keep pace with the rapid evolution of advanced devices.


The Korea Industrial Human Resources Agency (KIHRA), the exam's organizing body, had prepared by distributing detailed on-site identification manuals targeting 'artificial intelligence (AI) smart glasses.' However, it was confirmed that the device used by the top scorer was a different type of 'mini camera.' This has raised concerns that a monitoring network focused on specific devices inadvertently allowed the entry of other advanced technologies.


According to materials obtained by Aju Economy from the office of People Power Party lawmaker Park Soo-min, KIHRA significantly enhanced supervision by distributing 'smart glasses training materials' to 361 exam rooms across 20 test sites nationwide ahead of the second round of the tax accountant exam held on July 18.


The training materials distributed at that time detailed the physical characteristics of major smart glasses available on the market to on-site supervisors. Photos of various models, including Meta Ray-Ban (GEN2), the goggle-style Meta Oculus, and Alnoon from domestic manufacturer Sears Lab, were included, with the locations of camera lenses highlighted with blue borders.


Additionally, guidelines were issued to visually inspect specific design features during identity verification and to closely monitor candidates exhibiting unusual behaviors, such as 'continuous touching of the glasses' arms,' 'noise generation for voice recognition,' and 'lens illumination during camera operation.'


The problem lies in KIHRA's preemptive measures being overly focused on the single item of 'smart glasses.' The top scorer, identified as A, exploited a separate mini camera that was not in the form of glasses, penetrating the blind spots of the on-site monitoring network. A faced no restrictions or suspicions during both the first exam (Room 17 at Yongma Middle School) and the second exam (Room 19 at Seoul Semiconductor High School).


KIHRA had regulations in place to use metal detectors to search suspicious candidates if necessary, but throughout both exams, there were 'zero' cases of cheating detection or suspicion reports, and no unusual incidents were recorded in the supervision log.


The post-verification system designed to filter answers that passed through on-site monitoring was also inadequate for detecting advanced cheating. Since July of last year, KIHRA has established a 'Passer Review Committee' involving experienced personnel from the fields of computerization, question setting, and grading to conduct verification procedures before announcing passers.


However, this committee only checks for systemic errors, such as the registration of final answers, score input, and anomalies in grading program logic. There are no internal regulations in place for reviewing or cross-verifying the answers of top scorers or unusually high scorers.


Post-event improvements to the system have also been criticized. During the administration of the first and second tax accountant exams, only a general prohibition on the entry of electronic devices was communicated. Specific regulations prohibiting the entry of 'artificial intelligence (AI) devices' and 'smart glasses' were only reflected in a revised guideline after the exams concluded in September of this year.


The 'AI Inspector' system, which employs dedicated personnel to identify advanced devices like smart glasses, was first deployed in the exam hall for the real estate agent exam on October 31, after the tax accountant exam.


Ultimately, this incident only came to light after the top scorer's confession on YouTube went viral, leading to collective backlash from other candidates. As of 6 PM on November 16, KIHRA had received a total of 100 requests for thorough investigations and 27 requests for information disclosure. Based on the confession of the candidate, KIHRA completed a police complaint on November 16 and plans to incorporate the cheating methods identified during the investigation into future exam management.


Experts in education and evaluation have stated, 'This case illustrates that if authorities become fixated on identifying specific devices, they will inevitably become targets for other advanced technologies that are rapidly miniaturizing and becoming more intelligent. A comprehensive structural reform of the national qualification exam management system, including the introduction of post-verification algorithms for unusually high scorers through data analysis, is urgently needed.'





* This article has been translated by AI.