The failure of construction contract negotiations for the Czech Dukovany nuclear power project has put South Korea's nuclear export competitiveness to the test. Despite securing a contract worth tens of trillions of won, the country now faces the challenge of finding a new contractor to handle the actual construction. Observers suggest that the ability to manage promised construction costs and timelines will significantly influence the credibility of future South Korean nuclear exports.
◆ Construction permit application set for April, contractor selection delayed until July... Concerns over work gaps
According to the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy on the 18th, the government held the second 'Korea Hydro & Nuclear Power (KHNP) Project Review Meeting' chaired by Vice Minister Park Dong-il to assess follow-up measures for the Czech Dukovany nuclear project. Following the conclusion of construction contract negotiations between KHNP and the Daewoo Engineering & Construction and Doosan Enerbility consortium on September 29, the government has activated an emergency management system.
The key focus is to minimize work gaps that may arise during the contractor transition process. The Dukovany nuclear project involves the construction of two 1,000 megawatt (MW) APR1000 reactors. A main contract was signed between KHNP and the Czech ordering party last June, but a separate contract for actual construction has not been finalized.
While a construction permit application is scheduled for April next year, the target date for selecting a new contractor is three months later, in July. This means that necessary design and site-related tasks for permits must proceed without a confirmed contractor.
KHNP plans to either carry out these tasks directly or assign them to a local contractor in the Czech Republic, while separately issuing contracts for any new work required. They are developing a detailed management plan to be implemented weekly until the end of the year, dividing tasks such as design and permitting, site information verification, and accommodation site selection.
However, there remains the possibility of delays and additional costs. If continuity of work is not secured during the contractor transition, it could hinder subsequent contract signing and schedule management. Particularly, if urgent tasks are issued separately without clearly defining contract scope and responsibilities, conflicts over additional costs may arise again.
The background of the failed construction contract negotiations also involved disagreements over construction costs and risk sharing. KHNP has maintained the principle of a fixed-price contract while proposing measures to alleviate burdens due to fluctuations in quantities. In contrast, Daewoo Engineering & Construction argues that transferring the cost burden of increased construction quantities and additional work to the contractor is unreasonable in the absence of finalized designs.
◆ Lack of cost information sharing... Government pushes for nuclear export system reform
This situation has raised calls to review the overall contract and project cost management systems for nuclear export projects. A lack of information sharing among export agencies has previously hindered the effective utilization of past project experiences.
According to audit results released by the Board of Audit and Inspection in May, KHNP requested project cost data for the Barakah nuclear power plant in the United Arab Emirates from Korea Electric Power Corporation while preparing for the Czech nuclear bid, but was denied due to trade secrets. This has led to difficulties in estimating bid prices due to the inadequate use of cost information from past projects.
The Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy is working to streamline the nuclear export system by promoting the enactment of the Nuclear Export Promotion Act. This plan aims to strengthen government oversight by requiring consultation with the ministry before major decisions such as borrowing, investment, and signing export contracts. A system is also being developed to seek resolution through a dispute mediation committee composed of neutral experts in the event of disputes among participating companies.
In fact, after the negotiation breakdown, Daewoo Engineering & Construction requested mediation from the ministry for renegotiations, but the ministry stated it has no legal authority to mediate commercial contract negotiations between companies. While the government is reviewing the overall export business, its institutional means to intervene in individual contract disputes are limited.
Ultimately, to maintain competitiveness in nuclear exports, a system must support not only price competitiveness at the bidding stage but also risk management throughout the project execution process. It is crucial to clarify the standards for cost and risk sharing among participating companies and manage contract disputes to prevent them from causing delays in the overall project schedule. The ability to prove the 'completion within the set period and budget,' which has been touted as a strength of South Korean nuclear power, is expected to determine future export competitiveness.
Vice Minister Park Dong-il emphasized, "By thoroughly implementing a systematic plan that supports the achievement of key milestones, we will ensure the normal progress of the project," adding, "We must proceed more swiftly to prepare for unexpected schedule delay risks while adhering to quality and price commitments."
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.