Knowledge Industry Center Auction Prices Fall Below Appraisal Values

The knowledge industry centers, suffering from increased vacancies and unsold units, are facing challenges in the real estate project financing (PF) auction market promoted by financial authorities. Concerns are rising that the minimum auction prices for some properties are falling below half of their appraised values, which could increase the burden on financial institutions for recovering their loans.

An analysis of the "Current Status of Properties for Sale" released on the PF information disclosure platform on November 19 revealed that a total of eight knowledge industry centers have appeared on the sale list at least once from November last year to October this year. Among these, the total appraisal value of seven properties, for which the appraisal values and minimum auction prices can be compared, was 261.2 billion won (KRW), while the total minimum bid was only 110.2 billion won (KRW), representing just 42.2% of the appraisal value.

This figure represents the sum of the last publicly disclosed prices for each property and does not indicate the actual winning bid prices. In real estate auctions, if a property fails to sell, the minimum bid for the next round is often lowered. The extent of the price reduction varies depending on the auction conditions, and as repeated failures occur, the gap between the initial appraisal value and the minimum bid can widen.

For instance, the appraisal value of the knowledge industry center in Uijeongbu, Gyeonggi Province, is 30.51 billion won (KRW), but as of the end of last month, the minimum auction price was only 7.63 billion won (KRW), about 25% of the appraisal value.

Some properties have seen further reductions in their minimum bids. The knowledge industry center in Seongseong-dong, Cheonan, has maintained an appraisal value of 46.35 billion won (KRW), but its minimum bid was reduced from 34.03 billion won (KRW) to 30.63 billion won (KRW), a 10% decrease. Three other centers in Sin-gal-dong, Yongin, Chilgoe-dong, Pyeongtaek, and Bitgaram-dong, Naju, have remained on the sale list for nearly a year, waiting for a sale.

The issue is that delays in sales or winning bids below appraisal values could lead to increased burdens on financial institutions for recovering their loans. PF loans are typically repaid through the proceeds from sales or leases of development projects, so delays and price declines can hinder the recovery of principal. However, the actual scale of losses will vary depending on the winning bid price, remaining loan balances, and the seniority of the claims.

The difficulties in selling are attributed to the poor sales and leasing conditions of knowledge industry centers. According to the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy, the average vacancy rate for knowledge industry centers completed between 2023 and 2025 is 43.5%, with an unsold rate of 26.9%. Existing facilities are struggling to secure tenant demand, and with falling transaction prices and discounted sales from surrounding properties, it has become challenging for knowledge industry centers to even begin sales before construction.

An industry insider stated, "As the commercial real estate market has stagnated recently, buyers often wait for price reductions due to failed bids rather than participating in immediate auctions," adding, "As repeated failures lower the sale prices, the losses for financial companies could increase."





* This article has been translated by AI.