Gap Between Private and Public Redevelopment Incentives Narrows


Voices from the field indicate that the easing of regulations on private redevelopment projects has made it difficult to feel the competitive edge of public redevelopment. There are concerns that the expected benefits of floor area ratio incentives when choosing public redevelopment may diminish. Resident representatives have called for expanded support reflecting the conditions of each project site, mentioning future burdens of contributions and relocation costs.

Lee Sung-hoon, president of the Korea Land and Housing Corporation (LH), held a meeting on November 19 with resident representatives and construction company officials from public redevelopment projects at the Seoul headquarters to discuss difficulties in the project implementation process and improvement measures. This meeting followed President Lee Jae-myung's visit to the Jangwi 9 district on November 4, with attendees including representatives from Sinwol 7-dong 2 district, Jeonnong 9 district, and Garibong 2-92 district.

Public redevelopment is a method where the government participates in supporting projects in areas facing difficulties due to low project viability or conflicts among residents. The core goal is to enhance project viability and shorten project duration through floor area ratio incentives and financial and administrative support. On this day, resident representatives positively evaluated the transparency and stability of public redevelopment but emphasized the need for improvements in project viability.

A key issue was the gap in incentives compared to private redevelopment projects. As the Seoul city government has expanded regulatory easing benefits for private redevelopment projects, the relative advantages of public redevelopment may diminish.

Kim Young-ok, chairperson of the Garibong 2-92 district resident representative council, stated, "When we chose public redevelopment, there was an advantage in higher floor area ratio incentives compared to private redevelopment, but now that surrounding rapid integration planning projects are also being granted higher floor ratios, it has become difficult to feel the difference in project viability." He added, "I am worried that residents may feel anxious when future contributions are calculated."

In response, Lee explained, "The legal upper limit for floor area ratio in private redevelopment is 1.0 times, while for public redevelopment, it can be applied up to 1.2 times, and if legal amendments are made, it will increase to 1.3 times," outlining the potential for improving project viability. LH plans to analyze the project viability by district, considering that separate floor area ratio incentives apply to some private redevelopment projects in transit-oriented areas, and will also explore ways to reduce resident burdens through the use of special building zones.

The viability perceived by residents is influenced not only by floor area ratios but also by the volume of general sales and the scale of additional contributions. In particular, areas with height restrictions face limitations in fully utilizing floor area ratio incentives, which constrains project viability.

Sinwol 7-dong 2 district is a representative case. Ahn Woe-young, chairperson of the resident representative council, stated, "In a situation where it is difficult to fully utilize the floor area ratio due to height restrictions, the burden of low rental housing supply prices may also fall on residents," requesting government-level support. LH explained that it is proposing adjustments to the ratio of rental housing and donation burdens to the government, considering the unique characteristics of height-restricted areas.

In areas where projects have been fully initiated, securing relocation costs has emerged as another variable. Even if the permitting process proceeds smoothly, delays in relocation could disrupt construction schedules. There are concerns that in areas with many multi-homeowners, the restrictions on loans may make it difficult to secure relocation funds.

Shin Young-hwan, chairperson of the Jeonnong 9 district resident representative council, noted, "While the project is progressing quickly, many residents are asking about the possibility of loans for relocation costs for those with two homes," adding, "If relocation does not proceed smoothly, it will be difficult to move on to the next stage of the project." LH plans to explain the loan application criteria for homes within the redevelopment area and external properties and will further examine support measures for relocation costs for multi-homeowners.

Improving the permitting process was also presented as a task to accelerate project speed. Even with LH's support for public redevelopment, consultations with local governments are necessary during the review and permitting processes related to construction and redevelopment plans. Resident representatives requested that LH actively mediate to ensure that policy disagreements between the central government and Seoul city do not affect project timelines.

Based on the requests made on this day, LH plans to discuss adjustments to rental housing and donation burdens, financial support, and improvements to the permitting process with relevant agencies such as the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport and Seoul city.

Lee stated, "The goal of public redevelopment is to enhance project speed and transparency while leveraging the advantages of private redevelopment with public support," adding, "We will directly improve areas where LH can make improvements and actively propose matters that require consultation with relevant agencies to ensure smooth project implementation."




* This article has been translated by AI.