Kim Geon-hee Receives 4-Year Prison Sentence; Court Rules on Polling Costs


Kim Geon-hee has received a confirmed prison sentence of four years for her involvement in stock manipulation at Deutsche Motors and for accepting bribes in connection with the Unification Church. The Supreme Court ruled that it is difficult to view the election costs that former President Yoon Suk Yeol's side should bear as being covered by Myung Tae-kyun, who provided the results of the presidential election polls free of charge.

On November 19, the Supreme Court's full bench, led by Justice Park Young-jae, dismissed all appeals from Kim Geon-hee and the special counsel team led by Min Jung-ki regarding charges of violating the Capital Markets Act, the Political Fund Act, and bribery under the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Crimes. Consequently, the original sentence of four years in prison and a fine of 50 million won (KRW) has been upheld. The court also maintained the seizure of one Graff diamond necklace and an order for the return of 20.94 million won (KRW).

A key point of contention in the ruling was whether conducting a poll or providing its results constitutes a political fund donation under certain circumstances. The special counsel argued that Kim received polling results worth over 274 million won (KRW) from Myung 58 times from June 2021 to March 2022 in collusion with former President Yoon, applying the Political Fund Act violation.

The court determined that merely delivering polling results to a politician does not automatically establish a crime of receiving political funds. If an agreement is made for someone else to cover the polling costs that a politician should bear, it could be considered a political fund donation. Even if such an agreement is not confirmed, if the relationship between the parties, the timing and frequency of the polling, and its relevance to political activities are objectively clear, it could warrant punishment.

In Kim's case, the court found insufficient evidence to conclude that the former president and his wife had commissioned the polling from Myung or that they had agreed for him to cover the polling costs.

The majority opinion of the justices focused on the fact that Myung conducted the polling based on his own political beliefs or for the benefit of the Future Korea Institute and then shared some results with the couple. It concluded that this could not be definitively categorized as political activity costs borne by former President Yoon, nor was there intent to receive political funds from Kim.

However, a dissenting opinion was raised, arguing that the polling itself has intrinsic value that could be utilized for electoral strategy. If a third party conducts a poll at a cost and it is evaluated as part of a politician's campaign, and the politician benefits from it knowingly, it could be subject to punishment for receiving political funds.

The dissenting opinion suggested that even if Myung conducted the polling to enhance his political influence, it does not negate the benefits gained by the former president and his wife, and thus should be deemed guilty.

Kim's sentence increased from 1 year and 8 months in the first trial to 4 years in the appeals court due to the expanded scope of guilt regarding stock manipulation at Deutsche Motors and bribery involving the Unification Church.

The first trial had ruled that the statute of limitations had expired for some of the Deutsche Motors stock transactions and found the remaining charges of collusion with market manipulation forces to be unproven. In contrast, the appeals court viewed a series of market manipulation actions as a single crime, recognizing Kim's co-conspirator responsibility for transactions involving a securities account containing 2 billion won (KRW) entrusted to Black Pearl Investment.

Regarding the bribery from the Unification Church, the first trial acknowledged only one of the two items—a Graff necklace and two Chanel bags—received through Geonjinbeopsa Jeon Seong-bae as guilty. The appeals court ruled that Kim was aware of the implied request from the Unification Church seeking government cooperation when she received the remaining bag, thus finding her guilty of all bribery charges.

The standards set by this full court ruling are expected to apply to the appeal of former President Yoon, who was found guilty in the first trial and not guilty in the second trial for receiving polling results free of charge. The majority opinion in Kim's case ruled that the polling conducted by Myung could not be viewed as covering the political activity costs borne by former President Yoon.

In the case of Oh Se-hoon, the mayor of Seoul, who was indicted for receiving polling results from Myung, the issue at hand is the circumstances under which a donor covered the polling costs for Oh's side.




* This article has been translated by AI.