A prosecutor recently expressed skepticism about the special counsel law pushed by the ruling party, saying, "This will only create a world where criminals benefit." While the political arena calls for prosecution reform and the clarification of past investigations, the safety of the public and the functioning of the criminal justice system are being sidelined.
This marks the seventh special counsel since the current administration took office. It involves a record number of up to 309 personnel, including 20 prosecutors, 210 dispatched public officials, and 70 special investigators. The budget for the special counsel is 38 billion won (KRW), comparable to the combined budget of the three major special counsels for insurrection, Kim Geon-hee, and the Marine Corps, which totals 38.8 billion won (KRW).
The issue is that the large-scale personnel mobilization leads to operational gaps in frontline investigations. Cases handled by prosecutors and investigators dispatched to the special counsel are reassigned to other prosecutors and investigators. In an already overburdened situation, taking on a colleague's cases inevitably slows down the pace and quality of investigations and trials. As the capacity to thoroughly examine cases diminishes, the public bears the consequences.
Even more concerning is the low morale within the organization. One frontline investigator reported, "With case reassignments, overtime is unavoidable, and my motivation to work is dwindling." In an organization that should be sustained by a sense of justice and responsibility, there are even self-deprecating remarks suggesting, "If it’s like this, we might as well just work regular hours." The repeated mobilization of investigative personnel and the transfer of workloads to remaining staff cannot be considered a normal structure. There are limits to filling investigation gaps solely with a sense of mission.
This special counsel law raises concerns as it is being pushed during a transitional period for the criminal justice system. Although organizational restructuring has been carried out, focusing on the establishment of the Public Prosecution Service and the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency, the special counsel is designed to utilize the existing prosecution's personnel and investigative structure. While the institutional framework has changed, the personnel gaps and workload burdens have been shifted to frontline investigations. It is questionable how much the political arena has considered the confusion and side effects on the ground as it accelerates institutional reforms.
The purpose of prosecution reform is to decentralize power, enhance the independence and fairness of investigations, and protect the rights of the public. Abuses of prosecutorial power or politically motivated investigations must be corrected. However, reform cannot be completed merely by reducing investigative powers and reorganizing structures. It is necessary to answer whether there are alternatives, expertise, personnel, budgets, and systems in place to fill the investigation gaps. If the focus is solely on stripping away powers without measures to protect the public, the reform will only lead to further chaos.
The Democratic Party has emphasized that the separation of investigation and prosecution, driven by the complete deprivation of prosecutorial investigative powers, is an improvement for the public. Now, it must reflect on the outcomes of that choice in the field. By enforcing a special counsel law that includes investigations into presidential-related cases, it has invited controversy over constitutionality and legality, as well as debates about political neutrality. Even if the justification is strong to correct past prosecutorial errors, the interests of specific powers cannot take precedence over the public's criminal justice system.
The criminal justice system is not a testing ground for political parties. When there are gaps in investigations, criminals evade punishment, and the consequences fall squarely on ordinary citizens. Can a system that favors criminals and is harsh on victims truly be called a reform? If the focus remains solely on changing systems and powers while ignoring the safety of the public, the reform will lose its original purpose.
What the political arena must protect is not the face of the prosecution organization or the advantages of the regime. The state's duty is to conduct proper investigations and prevent unjust victims from arising. The government and the Democratic Party must not only be preoccupied with stripping away powers but should also listen to the voices from frontline investigations. As the saying goes, one should not shake the foundations of the criminal justice system while trying to fix certain problems. Prosecution reform should be evaluated not by how much power has been reduced but by how effectively the public has been protected from crime.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.