Supreme Court Overturns Partial Conviction of Han Duck-soo, Extends Detention by Two Months


The Supreme Court has partially overturned the conviction of former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo, who was sentenced to 15 years in prison in the second trial for charges including insurrection-related duties concerning the December 3 martial law situation. The court sent the case back to the Seoul High Court.

On the afternoon of November 19, the Supreme Court's full bench, led by Justice Oh Kyung-mi, held a hearing on Han's appeal regarding charges of insurrection-related duties and the creation of false public documents, and it overturned both the guilty and not guilty portions of the original ruling.

However, the Supreme Court maintained Han's detention status after the ruling and extended it by two months. This extension was made possible due to the remand, allowing for a renewal of the detention period in the lower court.

The main issue in this appeal was whether Han's actions before and after the declaration of martial law could be recognized as having the 'purpose of disrupting the constitution,' which is a key requirement for establishing the crime of insurrection.

A majority of the justices defined the declaration of martial law itself as an unconstitutional and illegal act that infringes on the basic rights of the people, but they argued that to hold individual participants responsible for insurrection-related duties, the purpose of disrupting the constitution must be strictly proven.

Accordingly, the majority opinion overturned the lower court's guilty ruling that found Han guilty for proposing to Yoon Suk Yeol, the former president, to convene a Cabinet meeting and for being involved in forming the so-called 'appearance of Cabinet deliberation' before the declaration of martial law.

The court cited that Han had expressed concerns about a decline in national credibility and public backlash before the declaration of martial law, indicating that he had indirectly opposed the declaration and had asked Cabinet members to dissuade Yoon.

Furthermore, it noted that since Yoon was in a situation where he was unilaterally attempting to declare martial law, Han did not have the legal authority to restrict the president's actions, and thus could not be definitively said to have the purpose of disrupting the constitution based solely on his inaction during the deliberation.

In contrast, regarding actions taken after the declaration of martial law, the Supreme Court upheld the lower court's guilty ruling. It determined that in a situation where martial law had been declared and the possibility of reversal had disappeared, Han's actions of pressuring Cabinet members to sign and discussing measures to block key institutions like the National Assembly and to cut off power to specific media outlets constituted active participation in insurrection.

The court also found Han guilty of signing a declaration cover document prepared post-facto by former presidential office aide Kang Yi-goo to remedy legal defects in the initial declaration and of demanding its destruction due to subsequent controversies, which violated the Presidential Records Act and damaged public documents.

Additionally, the Supreme Court found no error in the lower court's ruling that acquitted Han of perjury charges for denying the existence of documents during the impeachment trial at the Constitutional Court and for some insurrection-related duties.

However, Justices Oh Kyung-mi, Shin Sook-hee, and Kim Sung-soo expressed dissent, arguing that actions taken before the declaration of martial law should also be recognized as guilty. They pointed out that the existing ruling party's attempt to incapacitate the National Assembly by mobilizing the military, while cloaked in the constitutional procedure of Cabinet deliberation, functioned as a dangerous tool for completing the act of insurrection.

In particular, they noted that Han could have sufficiently recognized the unconstitutionality and illegality through the proclamation and directives issued on the day of the martial law declaration, yet he did not take explicit opposing actions for 1 hour and 30 minutes while ensuring the quorum was met. They argued that this indicated an implicit awareness and tolerance of constitutional disruption. They contended that segmenting these actions by time to absolve pre-declaration conduct was unjust.

The Supreme Court, while overturning the guilty portion due to a misunderstanding of legal principles regarding actions before the declaration of martial law, also ruled that the portions found not guilty in the lower court should be combined with the guilty portions under Article 37 of the Criminal Act, necessitating a single sentence. Thus, it overturned the entire ruling of the lower court and remanded the case to the Seoul High Court.

The special counsel team that indicted Han for insurrection, led by Special Counsel Cho Eun-seok, expressed respect for the Supreme Court's decision but also conveyed disappointment.

In a public statement, the special counsel noted, "There is substantial evidence supporting that Han proposed the Cabinet meeting to ensure legitimacy, allowing for selective summoning of Cabinet members to meet the quorum for mere formal procedures. This was proven beyond reasonable doubt in both the first and second trials, and we find disappointment in the Supreme Court's judgment."

They added, "We are also disappointed that the Supreme Court reached the same conclusion as the second trial regarding the judgment of insurrection-related duties by inaction, contrary to the first trial's recognition."

However, the special counsel emphasized, "The fact that the December 3 martial law was determined to be an insurrection aimed at disrupting the constitution has been confirmed for the first time through this ruling. This judicial determination will serve as a steadfast foundation for recognizing and punishing the reality of the December 3 insurrection," and stated, "The special counsel will ensure that ongoing related trials are conducted without being swayed by the contents of rulings at different levels until the final judgment is reached."




* This article has been translated by AI.