Heritage Committee Criticizes Seoul City Over Delays in Sewoon District Project

The National Heritage Committee has sharply criticized Seoul City regarding the controversy over heritage preservation related to the Sewoon District redevelopment project. The committee refuted Seoul's claim that the development has been delayed due to the committee's review, stating it is a "distortion of facts."

On the 20th, the committee's Subcommittee on Archaeological Heritage issued a statement saying, "Seoul City and the mayor have made claims that are inconsistent with the facts through social media and press releases," expressing "deep regret" over the matter.

The controversy arose recently concerning preservation measures for archaeological heritage unearthed at the Sewoon District urban environment improvement project site. Artifacts such as the city structure and daily life of the Joseon Dynasty, including a city gate and drainage systems, have been excavated in the area. The National Heritage Committee maintains that major heritage sites should be restored in their original locations while preserving the historical context of the surrounding space. In contrast, the project implementer has proposed adjusting the restoration locations of the heritage while maintaining the existing building plans, according to the committee.

The committee emphasized that 'preservation in situ' does not mean leaving all unearthed heritage exactly where it was found. The committee explained, "'Preservation in situ' means restoring important remains, such as the drainage system and city gate, to their original positions after the development project and connecting them to the old urban structure for public understanding of this valuable historical site." In this context, the committee highlighted that Seoul's claims of project delays are distortions, indicating that the city has not understood the purpose and process of the review.

The committee also criticized the project implementer for arbitrarily adjusting the restoration locations of the heritage to maintain building designs. It was noted that they intend to change the direction of the restoration of the northern drainage system to about 12 meters away from the excavation site. Additionally, the heritage to be restored on the basement level is positioned among commercial facilities, failing to adequately demonstrate the connection between the roads and drainage systems of that time. The committee's stance is that merely relocating the heritage to another site does not preserve its historical value. The relationship between the location and direction of the discovered heritage and the surrounding space, including the roads and drainage systems of that time, must be maintained.

The committee also called for respect for independent reviews. It stated that the preservation review of archaeological heritage is a separate process from the World Heritage Impact Assessment, limited to evaluating the appropriateness of preservation measures based on historical, academic, and artistic values.

The committee explained, "The requests for revisions after multiple reviews and on-site investigations are not intended to delay the project," adding, "They are meant to carefully consider preservation measures to ensure that the historical value of the important heritage of Hanyangdoseong is not compromised after development."

Furthermore, it stated, "It is not desirable to define the professional review process as an obstacle to development or to distort claims to make it a subject of controversy," urging Seoul City and the project implementer to respect the committee's professional review and independent judgment in finding a reasonable compromise between development and preservation.





* This article has been translated by AI.