Debate Over Cryptocurrency Loss Carryforward Deduction Period: 3 Years vs. 5 Years


The ruling and opposition parties have tentatively agreed on deferring cryptocurrency taxation and maintaining the basic deduction, while the duration of the loss carryforward deduction has emerged as a remaining issue. Industry voices are calling for the government to allow a 5-year carryforward period, as was previously intended for the financial investment income tax, rather than the 3 years proposed. Major countries like the U.S. and U.K. do not impose limits on the carryforward period, arguing that the high price volatility of cryptocurrencies should be taken into account.

According to financial and political sources on the 20th, the National Assembly's Finance and Economy Planning Committee reviewed a bill to amend the income tax law related to cryptocurrency taxation in a subcommittee meeting on the 17th, but did not reach a final decision. They tentatively agreed to postpone the implementation of the taxation, originally set for next year, to 2029 and to maintain the current basic deduction amount of 2.5 million won (KRW), but decided to discuss the carryforward deduction period further.

The loss carryforward deduction allows investors to offset losses incurred in one year against profits made in subsequent years for tax purposes. If a time limit is set for the deduction period, any losses that are not offset within that timeframe will be lost. On the 5th, the government announced a 3-year carryforward policy for cryptocurrency investment losses, and Democratic Party lawmaker An Do-geol also proposed a bill with the same content. According to this proposal, losses incurred in 2029 would only be deductible until 2032.
Financial Investment Tax is 5 Years; U.S. and U.K. Have No Limits... Calls for 5-Year Extension
Among cryptocurrency industry participants and investors, there is a consensus that the 3-year deduction period is insufficient. Due to the high price volatility of cryptocurrencies, frequent stop-loss orders occur, and exchanges between coins are subject to taxation, meaning that losses are realized at the moment of switching. If an investor confirms a loss and it takes more than 3 years for the market to recover, they will not be able to deduct past losses from future profits.

For example, if an investor buys cryptocurrency for 50 million won (KRW) in 2029 and sells it for 40 million won (KRW), they will realize a loss of 10 million won (KRW). Even if they later earn a profit of 10 million won (KRW) from cryptocurrency investments in 2033, their cumulative profit and loss will be zero.

However, if the carryforward deduction period is 3 years, the loss incurred in 2029 can only be deducted until 2032. Consequently, the 10 million won (KRW) profit in 2033 would be subject to a 22% tax rate after excluding the basic deduction of 2.5 million won (KRW), resulting in a tax payment of 1.65 million won (KRW). In contrast, if the carryforward deduction period is extended to 5 years, the past losses can be deducted, eliminating any tax liability.

There are also differences compared to other domestic income types. The now-defunct financial investment income tax was designed to allow a 5-year carryforward of losses from financial investments such as stocks and bonds. Business income losses can generally be carried forward for 15 years.

Major countries abroad also broadly allow loss carryforwards for cryptocurrency investment losses. The U.S. and U.K. tax capital gains from cryptocurrency transfers without imposing limits on the carryforward period. Japan is reforming its cryptocurrency taxation system to align it with financial products, introducing a 3-year carryforward for losses from specific cryptocurrency transactions.

Professor Hwang Seok-jin of Dongguk University’s Graduate School of International Information Security stated, "The loss carryforward deduction is significant in securing the principles of real income taxation and tax equity," adding, "Considering the recent market downturn and the high price volatility of cryptocurrencies, it is necessary to consider extending the carryforward period to more than 5 years in the long term."




* This article has been translated by AI.