Former Shinhan Card CEO Acquitted of Hiring Fraud Charges


The Seoul Central District Court acquitted former Shinhan Card CEO Wi Seong-ho and a former HR team leader of charges related to providing preferential treatment to certain applicants during the hiring process. The court overturned the lower court's guilty verdict, stating that it could not definitively conclude that the final hiring decision was illegal based solely on differing evaluations between the interview panel and the final decision-maker.

On November 11, the court's Criminal Appeals Division 2-3, led by judges Jo Eun-ah, Kwak Jeong-hwan, and Kim Yong-hee, reversed the lower court's sentence of 10 months in prison with a two-year probation for Wi and six months in prison with a two-year probation for the former HR team leader.

The court reasoned that the mere fact that the evaluations of the interview panel differed from those of the final hiring decision-maker did not automatically indicate that improper hiring had occurred. It suggested that there was a possibility that the applicants' abilities were further verified during the hiring process, and thus, differences in evaluation results alone could not be seen as a failure to follow proper procedures.

Additionally, the court explained that deeming the final decision-maker's actions of considering the objective qualifications and abilities of certain applicants as illegal could undermine the very authority of the hiring decision itself.

After reviewing the hiring process for each applicant along with their objective qualifications and abilities, the court concluded that the evidence presented by the prosecution was insufficient to establish that improper hiring occurred or that the interview process was obstructed. This ruling overturned the lower court's finding that some applicants passed the selection process based solely on Wi's personal decisions.

Previously, Wi and others were indicted for allegedly obstructing fair hiring practices by accepting requests from executives of Shinhan Financial Group affiliates and creating a list of eight recommended candidates, some of whom were ultimately hired between 2016 and 2017.

The prosecution had identified that some candidates on the recommendation list did not meet the criteria for the document screening but still passed the selection process. They also alleged that scores of candidates who did not qualify in the first and second interviews were manipulated to ensure their final acceptance.

The so-called Shinhan Financial Group hiring scandal came to light in May 2018 when the Financial Supervisory Service reported evidence of preferential hiring practices at major affiliates, including Shinhan Card, Shinhan Bank, and Shinhan Life, leading to a criminal investigation. Prior to this appeal ruling, Jo Yong-byeong, the former chairman of Shinhan Financial Group, was acquitted by the Supreme Court in June 2022 on similar hiring fraud charges.




* This article has been translated by AI.