Financial authorities have decided to enhance the authority of independent directors to oversee bank holding company chairpersons, but the key issue remains whether the selection process will change significantly. Even if opportunities for shareholder recommendations are expanded, the effectiveness of oversight could be limited if candidate vetting and final recommendations continue to rely on existing networks.
According to the Financial Services Commission and the Financial Supervisory Service on November 12, the plan to improve governance structures for financial companies includes allowing shareholders with a certain percentage of ownership in listed financial companies to directly recommend independent director candidates. The proposal also includes prohibiting current CEOs from participating in the nomination committee for independent director candidates and suggesting that the committee be composed entirely of independent directors.
However, a special inspection by the Financial Supervisory Service of eight bank holding companies revealed that existing external recommendation channels did not lead to actual appointments. For instance, at A Financial Group, 56.8% of the candidates in the pool for outside directors were recommended by external organizations, yet none were appointed. Similarly, B Financial Group had 41.3% of its candidate pool from external recommendations, but again, none were appointed. Even in a holding company where external recommendations made up 80.3% of the candidate pool, only 22.2% of the appointed outside directors were from external recommendations.
In contrast, candidates directly recommended by existing outside directors were sometimes appointed without sufficient vetting. One holding company included a candidate recommended by an outside director in the final candidate pool on the same day without detailed evaluations or background checks, and then recommended them as the final candidate ten days later. Another holding company similarly added a candidate to the final pool without qualification verification on the day they were included, recommending them two weeks later.
The existing external recommendation process differs from the newly introduced shareholder recommendation system. However, there are concerns that even with external candidates, the actual appointment process may not change, highlighting the importance of applying fair vetting standards to both internal and external candidates.
The Financial Services Commission has proposed allowing shareholders who have held at least 0.1% of shares for more than six months to recommend candidates. As of the end of last year, there were 1,216 shareholders, including 1,131 institutional investors and 85 individual shareholders, holding at least 0.1% of shares in seven listed bank holding companies.
Efforts are also underway to clarify interpretations that would encourage institutional investors like the National Pension Service to participate. The aim is to reduce the burden on institutional investors by clarifying that recommending independent director candidates at the request of financial companies does not constitute an attempt to influence management rights.
Recommendations from institutional investors will be voluntary, and the recommended candidates will undergo verification and recommendation processes by the nomination committee before being finally appointed at the shareholders' meeting. Financial authorities plan to require the disclosure of the list of candidates recommended by shareholders in the governance structure annual report, regardless of whether they are appointed, to allow external verification of whether recommended candidates lead to actual appointments.
The process for reappointing independent directors also requires improvement. The special inspection found that all outside directors received top or near-top ratings, with no instances of replacement based on evaluations. Some holding companies awarded perfect scores in evaluation criteria simply for attending meetings, regardless of the frequency or content of their contributions.
Financial authorities plan to incorporate independent directors' statements and requests for information into the evaluation for reappointment and to strengthen the disclosure of their activities. For the expansion of candidate recommendation channels to effectively lead to genuine oversight of management, fair vetting must be operational from the initial appointment through the reappointment evaluation.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.