Former KCC Chairman Han Sang-hyuk Acquitted in TV Chosun Reapproval Scandal

 

Han Sang-hyuk, the former chairman of the Korea Communications Commission (KCC), and five others involved in the alleged manipulation of TV Chosun's reapproval scores were acquitted in a first trial.

The Seoul Northern District Court's Criminal Division 13, led by Judge Na Sang-hoon, ruled on November 12 that all defendants, including Han and former officials from the KCC, were not guilty of charges including obstruction of public duty, abuse of authority, and forgery of official documents.

The court stated, "The allegations against the defendants do not meet the criteria for proving a crime."

The defendants were accused of conspiring to lower and manipulate evaluation scores during the 2020 reapproval process for comprehensive programming channels, in order to deny or conditionally approve TV Chosun's reapproval after it exceeded the passing score without any failures. They were indicted in 2023.

Additionally, following an audit by the Board of Audit and Inspection in September 2022 that raised these allegations, the KCC was accused of preparing and distributing false press materials stating that it did not interfere with the evaluation process.

Previously, prosecutors sought a three-year prison sentence for Han, two years and six months for the former KCC director and deputy director, two years for the reapproval evaluation chair, and one year and six months for the two evaluation committee members.

While the court expressed some skepticism regarding the score modification actions, it did not recognize the conspiracy allegations. The court noted, "Although there are suspicions of intent to manipulate, as seen in the change of TV Chosun's critical evaluation item from passing to failing, the evidence presented does not sufficiently prove conspiracy beyond reasonable doubt."

The court cited that the KCC's broadcasting policy director had been informed of the score modifications and responded, 'That won't do,' and that the score changes occurred before the final evaluation report was approved, making it difficult to acknowledge illegality.

Furthermore, claims of abuse of discretion in the composition of the evaluation committee and Han's remarks upon receiving reports were dismissed due to insufficient credibility of the testimonies.

Regarding the charge of preparing false press materials, the court found no evidence of intent or awareness of falsification.

Following the verdict, Han issued a statement saying, "Common sense and truth have found their rightful place," and asserted that the so-called 'targeted investigation' that transformed lawful administrative procedures and policy judgments into crimes has been revealed in court."





* This article has been translated by AI.