Several years ago, the issue of 'garbage mountains' captured national attention. These illegal dumping practices involved piling thousands of tons of waste on abandoned factory sites or leased land, with perpetrators disappearing without a trace. Following a comprehensive government investigation in 2019 and amendments to the Waste Management Act, many of these garbage mountains were largely cleared.
But has illegal dumping disappeared? Unfortunately, the answer is no. What has vanished is the visible 'form' of garbage mountains, not the act of illegal dumping itself. Waste that once piled on the ground has simply moved underground, giving rise to what can be termed 'garbage fields.'
The methods have become more sophisticated. Under the guise of land improvement or site development, waste is mixed with soil and buried, masquerading as legitimate fill. This so-called 'illegal fill and backfill' is presented as compliant with recycling standards, complete with contracts and test results, and is brought in during daylight hours in large quantities. To the untrained eye, it appears to be a normal construction site. Once the filling is complete and covered with soil, any trace of the waste is concealed.
The Soil Speaks Late
According to data presented at a September 2026 forum on illegal waste fill held at the National Assembly, there have been 75 confirmed cases of illegal fill, amounting to over 1.35 million tons. However, this figure does not represent the total scale of illegal fill; it only reflects the 'exposed' cases. Waste buried underground does not reveal itself easily. The actual scale is likely much larger.
Once the filling is completed, the land becomes indistinguishable from surrounding fields. However, contaminants gradually spread underground, and by the time the problem surfaces, the damage is often extensive. This risk was starkly illustrated in Ulsan's Ulju County, where operators disguised approximately 46,000 tons of waste sludge and contaminated soil as legitimate fill. The total value of the illegally filled land is estimated to be less than 200 million won, while the cost of restoration exceeds 13 billion won. Selling the land would only cover a fraction of the restoration costs.
So who bears the remaining burden? Landowners, local governments, and ultimately, taxpayers. If illegal fill is not prevented in advance, the costs of post-restoration will be substantial, and the entire society will shoulder that burden. At this point, illegal fill cannot simply be viewed as a violation of waste disposal regulations. It poses a serious environmental crime that threatens soil, groundwater, crops, and food safety, while shifting the burden of damage recovery onto landowners and communities.
The Gap Between 'How High' and 'With What'
Why does this issue keep recurring? In dealing with environmental incidents, it becomes clear that much of the problem stems not from a lack of regulation but from disconnections between existing regulations. Regulations governing the movement of waste and those related to land use are thorough within their respective domains, but there is insufficient continuity where these two areas intersect.
Waste is tracked through a computerized system from its generation to final disposal. However, once it is recycled and becomes a 'product,' tracking becomes impossible. There is inadequate oversight to confirm where that product is actually buried and in what quantity. The administrative structure reflects this gap as well. The department responsible for development permits focuses on the height and area of fill, while the waste management department checks compliance with recycling standards. Each department has clear questions, but there is a lack of a consistent system to verify where the soil came from and where it is used. Illegal fill exploits this gap between the two regulatory systems.
It's Time to Shift the Focus of Response
Responses to date have often come only after damage has been revealed. By the time buried waste is discovered, the perpetrator has often vanished or lacks the resources to cover restoration costs, leaving the burden entirely on the community. It is now essential to shift the focus from post-restoration to proactive prevention. To achieve this, at least three measures are necessary.
First, there must be continuous tracking from the point of waste generation to the final site of use. For fill operations above a certain scale, management should link the source, transport vehicles, quantities brought in, and the land used, while comparing permitted fill amounts with actual quantities.
Second, the processes for development permits and waste management must be integrated. The type of fill material, its source, and quality inspection results should be verified in advance, and the import process must be effectively supervised. Having the necessary paperwork does not guarantee the safety of the soil. Moreover, considering the practice of bringing in intermediate processed waste and mixing it directly on-site, known as 'on-site recycling,' there is an even greater need to strengthen verification during the import and mixing stages.
Third, a system must be established to hold actual perpetrators accountable. Illegal dumping often involves organized networks of waste generators, brokers, and transporters. Simply punishing those caught in the act will not sever these connections. A comprehensive investigative system that traces the flow of waste and money is needed, along with securing criminal proceeds and responsible assets.
Additionally, for high-risk fill operations above a certain scale, it may be necessary to consider a restoration performance bond that accounts for waste disposal costs. Public resources should also be made available to ensure swift restoration, even if the perpetrator disappears or lacks resources.
System Improvements Must Lead to Change on the Ground
Improvements to the system have already been made. The 2019 amendment to the Waste Management Act significantly expanded the scope of responsibility for illegal waste disposal. In September, two amendments to the National Land Planning Act were proposed, mandating the designation of supervisors and the deposit of performance bonds for fill operations above a certain scale. In October, an amendment to the Waste Management Act was proposed, requiring approval of supply plans and computerized input for waste or recycled aggregates used as fill material, along with reporting to the relevant administrative authorities. Legal mechanisms to hold parties accountable for illegal waste disposal are already in place, and discussions on strengthening preventive legislation are ongoing. However, the more critical task is to create an environment where these laws can function effectively.
Garbage mountains were visible, allowing for their identification and removal. However, garbage fields are difficult to detect until damage becomes apparent. Therefore, illegal fill cannot be left solely to the enforcement and restoration efforts of individual local governments. A national-level management system is urgently needed to fill the gaps in responsibility from waste generation to final use.
The more frightening aspect is the invisible garbage fields. We must not stop at clearing the visible garbage mountains but also prevent new garbage fields from forming underground. Stopping waste before it is buried is the path to protecting the environment and reducing social costs.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.