Shincheonji Investigation Concludes, Legal Dilemmas Persist for Ruling Party

The Democratic Party of Korea concluded its confidential review of the "Shincheonji allegations investigation" on November 13. Following individual reviews by lawmakers, demands for a comprehensive member investigation and emergency disciplinary measures from Song Young-gil and others have intensified, alongside pressure from the pro-Cheongrae faction for full disclosure of the member list. Political and legal analysts suggest that verifying and disclosing the list could lead to further controversies regarding the Personal Information Protection Act.

According to political sources, the conflict surrounding the Democratic Party's allegations of Shincheonji's collective membership could escalate into legal disputes. A key issue remains the manner in which the member list, containing over 100,000 names, was obtained, as this information has not yet been disclosed.

A legal expert told Aju Economy that "the judgment may vary depending on how the list was obtained," adding that if the Democratic Party proceeds with its own investigation or discloses the list without clarity on its acquisition, it could lead to legal controversies.

The act of comparing the party member list with that of an external religious organization could be contentious. Article 23 of the Personal Information Protection Act defines "thought and belief" and "joining or leaving a political party" as sensitive information. Legal experts argue that both the party member list and the Shincheonji list contain sensitive information, and filtering out church members from these lists could be seen as creating new religious data.

To process such sensitive information, explicit consent from the individuals involved or a clear legal basis is required. Current party laws do not provide grounds for a political party to verify its members' religious affiliations, raising concerns that without consent, violations of the Personal Information Protection Act could arise.

In this context, Choi Soo-jin, the chief spokesperson for the People Power Party, remarked on November 8 that "the Democratic Party, lacking investigative authority, must clarify how it obtained external data to compare it with the lists of its 1.55 million members."

The proposals for a comprehensive member investigation and emergency disciplinary measures advocated by Song and others, as well as the pro-Cheongrae faction's demand for full disclosure with personal information redacted, face significant practical challenges. Since political parties lack compulsory investigative powers, any illegal actions taken during the collection and comparison of the lists would not be absolved even with de-identification.

Meanwhile, the People Power Party has intensified its offensive, labeling the allegations as "criminal suspicions" that warrant investigation by law enforcement. The People Power Party itself faced a similar controversy in the past, resulting in police raids.

Jung Jeom-sik, the floor leader of the People Power Party, stated, "The issue cannot be resolved simply by former and current leaders of the Democratic Party meeting privately to apologize. The ruling party must also undergo thorough investigations regarding the Shincheonji allegations. The People Power Party will pursue a special investigation law."




* This article has been translated by AI.