Human Rights Commission: Excluding Non-Tenured Professors from Chancellor Selection is Discrimination


The National Human Rights Commission has determined that excluding non-tenured faculty from faculty council participation and the chancellor selection process constitutes unreasonable discrimination. The commission emphasized that non-tenured faculty are integral members of the university community and should be granted the right to participate in decision-making processes.

According to the commission on November 16, non-tenured faculty at A University, a private institution in Daegu, filed a complaint last November after being excluded from faculty council meetings and the chancellor selection process.

The university argued that the faculty council is an autonomous decision-making body, unlike the university council, which is mandated by law. They maintained that the current operational practices are based on traditions formed around job security and long-term accountability for faculty members, and that these issues should be resolved through consensus within the tenured faculty community.

However, the commission's discrimination correction committee concluded that excluding non-tenured faculty from the faculty council and chancellor selection process lacks a reasonable basis for discrimination.

The commission recognized that non-tenured faculty continuously engage in educational and research activities and hold positions that allow them to influence university operations.

The university conducts reappointment reviews for non-tenured faculty every two years, allowing reappointment until the age of 65. Those who have served as assistant professors for over six years and meet promotion criteria may advance to associate professor.

Additionally, the faculty council is an official body that deliberates and decides on matters related to education, research, academic operations, faculty status and rights, welfare, university management, and major regulations. The chancellor also exercises authority over university operations and has the right to recommend appointments for non-tenured faculty.

The commission pointed out that the roles of the faculty council and chancellor have direct and indirect impacts on the working conditions and rights of non-tenured faculty, indicating that there is no reasonable justification for restricting their participation.

As a result, the commission recommended that the chairperson of the university's board of trustees and the chancellor amend relevant regulations to allow non-tenured faculty to participate in the chancellor selection process. The commission also urged the chairperson of the faculty council to revise regulations to ensure membership eligibility for non-tenured faculty.




* This article has been translated by AI.