Korea's fuel cap faces budget scrutiny

This combination photo shows fuel prices displayed at a gas station in Seoul on April 22 2026 left and the National Assembly building in Yeouido Seoul on May 19 2026 AJP Han Jun-gu
This combination photo shows fuel prices displayed at a gas station in Seoul on April 22, 2026 (left), and the National Assembly building in Yeouido, Seoul, on May 19, 2026. AJP Han Jun-gu.
SEOUL, November 16 (AJP) — South Korea has allocated or proposed a combined 5.65 trillion won ($4.2 billion) across two fiscal years to cushion consumers against soaring fuel prices, drawing scrutiny over how the compensation bill is calculated and how further extensions would be funded.

The government extended the cap for another four weeks on Friday, keeping maximum supply prices at 1,784 won per liter for gasoline, 1,773 won for diesel and 1,380 won for kerosene. The latest ceilings took effect Saturday, continuing a policy introduced in March to contain imported inflation.

Dubai crude has retreated to around $90 a barrel from October’s higher levels but remains more than $20 above its late-June price. Shipping costs have also stayed elevated amid security risks around the Strait of Hormuz, according to the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Resources.

The government has secured 4.2 trillion won in contingency funding to compensate refiners for losses incurred during the first three quarters of 2026. Another 1.45 trillion won has been proposed in the ministry’s 2027 budget, primarily to cover losses arising in the final quarter of this year.

The combined figure represents available or proposed funding, not actual expenditure. It also excludes the potential cost of maintaining the controls throughout 2027.

That distinction is central to questions raised by the National Assembly Budget Office (NABO), which challenged the reliability of the government’s compensation estimates in its October review of the proposed 2027 budget.

Of the proposed 1.45 trillion won, 1.449 trillion won is intended for refiner compensation. The remainder would cover administrative expenses, including the settlement committee.

The ministry told NABO that its estimate was based on simulations using, among other inputs, international oil price forecasts from the Korea Energy Economics Institute. The budget office said detailed simulation data had not been provided at the time of its review.

The final bill could vary significantly depending on how long the cap remains in place, international crude prices, exchange rates, domestic sales volumes and the gap between regulated prices and recognized supply costs.

Even the first settlement, covering March 13 through June 30, remained incomplete as of Oct. 6, according to the report.

At a public briefing Friday, ministry officials said that settlement was nearing completion and that compensation calculated under the government’s cost-based rules should remain within the existing contingency allocation.

The amount is expected to be disclosed by late November or early December. Payments could be completed this year, although objections from refiners could delay disbursement.

The calculation method remains a point of contention between the government and the refining industry.

The ministry says compensation should reflect actual costs and reasonable profits. Refiners have sought to use Singapore benchmark petroleum product prices, known as MOPS, to account for the opportunity cost of supplying fuel domestically rather than selling it abroad.

The government has rejected that approach, arguing that compensation based on international market prices would undermine the purpose of the domestic cap.

In an Oct. 17 explanation, the ministry said industry estimates of 7 trillion to 8 trillion won in accumulated losses reflected potential earnings rather than costs eligible for reimbursement.

The eventual fiscal burden therefore cannot be calculated simply by comparing international product prices with the government’s ceilings. It will depend on the settlement committee’s assessment of refiners’ actual costs and eligible sales.
 
Edited and compiled by AJP Graphics AI assisted
Edited and compiled by AJP. Graphics AI assisted.
An extension into 2027 would create a separate funding question.

The proposed government budget includes 3.5 trillion won in earmarked contingency reserves for specified purposes, including responses to high oil prices and supply-chain disruptions.

The Ministry of Planning and Budget has said the reserves were intended partly to prepare for fuel price controls continuing next year. The entire amount, however, is not dedicated to refiner compensation.

NABO questioned whether contingency reserves should finance costs that become foreseeable when the government extends the cap.

In its review of the overall 2027 budget, the office argued that reasonably predictable compensation should be funded through the regular budget, leaving contingency reserves for unexpected additional expenditure.

Relying on reserves for foreseeable spending could limit lawmakers’ ability to examine the expected costs before approving the budget, it warned.

NABO recommended that the ministry prepare spending scenarios based on different termination dates and revise its estimates once actual settlement figures become available.

The lag between refiners incurring losses and receiving compensation further complicates fiscal planning.

Losses from the final quarter of 2026 are expected to be settled next year because refiners must submit supporting documents after the accounting period ends. Compensation for any additional losses incurred under continued controls in 2027 would come on top of those obligations.

The cap has nevertheless provided measurable relief from inflation.

A Korea Development Institute (KDI) study released Thursday estimated that the policy lowered petroleum product price inflation by an average of about 12 percentage points between March and October. It reduced overall consumer price inflation by an estimated 0.6 percentage point on average.

KDI also estimated that the recent oil price shock could shave about 0.4 percentage point off private consumption growth in 2026, although its model captured the mitigating effects of the cap only to a limited extent.

Recent Bank of Korea data illustrate why falling crude prices alone offer little certainty about the compensation bill.

Won-denominated import prices fell 1.8 percent in October from September as crude prices declined and the currency strengthened. Import prices for coal and petroleum products, however, rose 3.5 percent.

Those movements do not establish refiners’ eligible compensation costs, but they underscore the limits of using crude prices alone to estimate the government’s liability.

The first settlement, expected by early December, should give lawmakers a firmer basis for assessing the proposed 1.45 trillion won compensation budget.

If the cap continues next year, the government will face a further test: how much of the additional bill it can reasonably anticipate — and how much should be submitted to parliamentary scrutiny through the regular budget.