APEC Summit: Unprepared US-China-Russia Meeting Highlights Xi Jinping's Diplomatic Gamble

The leaders of the United States, China, and Russia are scheduled to hold a summit on November 19 in Shenzhen, China, but reports indicate they have failed to agree on an agenda in advance. This is a notably unusual format for Chinese President Xi Jinping, who typically prefers to establish a diplomatic agenda and coordinate outcomes before meetings. Analysts suggest that Xi is taking on significant diplomatic burdens in dealing with the unpredictable styles of U.S. President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin.


The Financial Times reported on November 16 that while the three countries agreed to hold the summit, they could not set specific discussion topics beforehand. Initially, China was reportedly reluctant to host the summit due to the unpredictable negotiation styles of Trump and Putin, which could pose diplomatic challenges for Xi.


China has favored a diplomatic approach that involves coordinating discussion topics ahead of the summit and agreeing on outcomes in advance. This method typically allows leaders to exchange prepared remarks and issue a joint statement. However, the U.S. side prefers open exchanges of ideas, leading to unresolved differences over setting a pre-agenda. After weeks of negotiations, China ultimately agreed to hold the summit without a pre-established agenda.


The United Daily News mentioned on November 17 that key issues likely to be discussed at the summit include nuclear disarmament, the war in Ukraine, and the situation in Iran. The U.S. is seeking to involve China in nuclear disarmament discussions, while Russia is interested in securing negotiation space with the U.S. regarding the Ukraine conflict. Trump may also raise the issue of Iran's nuclear program. However, given the differing interests among the three nations, reaching a concrete agreement is expected to be challenging.


Particularly, there are clear differences in positions regarding nuclear disarmament. The U.S. argues that China should participate in discussions on nuclear weapons control and reduction, but China has shown reluctance, citing that the nuclear capabilities of the U.S. and Russia far exceed its own. Regarding Ukraine, Russia wants to engage in discussions, but China maintains that Europe should be at the center of negotiations. The situation in Iran also presents mismatched interests among the U.S., China, and Russia. Reports indicate that Russia hopes to adopt a joint statement at this summit, but coordinating the content of such a statement is likely to be difficult given the lack of a pre-agreed agenda.


For Xi, this summit presents an opportunity to enhance China's international standing by meeting simultaneously with the leaders of the U.S. and Russia. However, the lack of prior coordination means he will have to respond spontaneously to the demands of Trump and Putin, which could be burdensome. Furthermore, it is crucial for China to avoid giving the impression that it supports one side over the other. Ultimately, the significance of this summit may lie more in the fact that the three leaders gathered to discuss global issues than in their ability to narrow sharp differences in interests and reach substantive agreements.





* This article has been translated by AI.