As the leaders of the United States, China, and Russia prepare to discuss international security issues such as nuclear disarmament and the Iran situation in their first-ever trilateral summit, attention is focused on the potential impact of this meeting on the global order. Beyond the possibility of concrete agreements, this summit may serve as a pivotal moment for the three leaders to directly coordinate the management of nuclear order and international conflicts. However, there are concerns that issues such as the Ukraine war and East Asian security could become bargaining chips among the great powers. If South Korea is sidelined in the discussions regarding the Korean Peninsula, significant repercussions for its diplomatic and security landscape are anticipated.
According to diplomatic sources on November 19, President Donald Trump of the United States, President Xi Jinping of China, and President Vladimir Putin of Russia are set to hold their first trilateral summit at the Qilin Mountain Resort in Shenzhen, Guangdong Province, China. The White House had previously indicated that the main agenda items for the summit would include global nuclear weapons reduction and the Iran issue.
This summit is noteworthy as it could mark the beginning of new negotiations to fill the gap in nuclear disarmament following the termination of the New START treaty between the U.S. and Russia. Since the Cold War, nuclear disarmament negotiations have been led by the U.S. and the Soviet Union, and later by the U.S. and Russia. However, concerns have been raised that managing the international nuclear order has become increasingly difficult due to China's expanding nuclear capabilities.
Nonetheless, given the diverging interests of the three countries, it is unlikely that specific agreements on the scale of nuclear weapons reduction or verification methods will be reached during the initial meeting. Observers suggest that the focus will likely be on establishing a basic direction for future discussions. Whether the summit will be a one-time event or evolve into a forum for ongoing coordination on nuclear disarmament and international disputes will determine its future success.
The Iran issue is also a key agenda item where the interests of the three countries intersect. The U.S. aims to prevent Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons and to reduce support from China and Russia for Iran, while China and Russia have emphasized solutions through ceasefires and negotiations rather than military pressure and sanctions. If the three countries can agree on minimal principles such as preventing escalation and verifying nuclear facilities, China may emerge as a mediator in subsequent negotiations. Conversely, if they cannot narrow their differences, the Iran conflict could remain another front in the U.S.-China-Russia rivalry extending into the Middle East.
Professor Joo Jinho of Kyung Hee University stated, "It is unlikely that concrete agreements will emerge from the first summit, but even establishing a framework for future discussions would be a significant achievement. If the positions of the three countries can be somewhat aligned, that alone would be meaningful."
The Ukraine war is also a significant issue related to the potential repercussions of this summit. While U.S. officials have stated that the Ukraine war will not be addressed as an official agenda item, there remains the possibility that Russia may seek China's role in peace negotiations. Particularly, if negotiations proceed in a manner that effectively recognizes the territories occupied by Russia, there are concerns that this could set a precedent for accepting changes to the status quo through force. If Ukraine and Europe are excluded from the negotiation process and the direction of the war is determined by agreements among great powers, it could send the wrong signals to North Korea.
Research Fellow Doo Jin-ho of the Institute for East Asian Studies at Kyungnam University noted, "There is a possibility that the U.S. and Russia will explain the current negotiation situation, their differences, and areas of potential agreement to China, requesting a certain role. In that process, Europe could be effectively sidelined, and the recent 'Alliance of Will' meeting in Europe can be seen as a response to this."
Experts emphasize that the South Korean government must first understand how the Korean Peninsula issue is addressed in discussions among the three countries through consultations with the U.S. Reflecting South Korea's security concerns, including the North Korean nuclear threat, in future U.S.-China-Russia negotiations is also considered a major task.
Professor Lim Eul-chul of Kyungnam University predicts that while discussions on nuclear disarmament among the U.S., China, and Russia may exert psychological pressure on North Korea, it is unlikely to lead to substantial changes in North Korea's nuclear strategy. He explained that the official U.S. policy toward North Korea remains denuclearization, and the mere statements of the U.S. president do not institutionally recognize North Korea's status as a nuclear power.
Research Fellow Kim Doo-yeon of the Asan Institute for Policy Studies stated, "Recognizing the reality that North Korea possesses nuclear weapons is entirely different from acknowledging North Korea as a nuclear power. There are concerns that in future negotiations, the denuclearization goal may be sidelined, effectively legitimizing North Korea's permanent nuclear armament. Furthermore, if South Korea is excluded from discussions among great powers or U.S.-North Korea dialogue, it could negatively impact trust and the alliance between South Korea and the U.S."
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.