APEC Special Report: The Politics of Power and Protocol from Stalin to Xi Jinping

Countries possess power, and diplomacy involves protocol. National power is measured by economic and military strength, but protocol often reveals power dynamics that cannot be quantified. Who comes to greet at the airport? Who extends their hand first? Who sits next to whom, and who sees whom off last? In seemingly trivial gestures lie a nation's pride and a leader's calculations.


In diplomacy, chance is rare, especially in meetings of great power leaders.


On November 18, 2026, at Shenzhen Bao'an International Airport in China, U.S. President Donald Trump was personally welcomed by Chinese President Xi Jinping as he stepped off Air Force One. The two leaders shared a handshake followed by a brief hug. Five Chinese fighter jets flew overhead in a celebratory display. This direct reception of a foreign leader by the top Chinese leader at the airport was an unprecedented scene, breaking decades of protocol.


On the same day, Russian President Vladimir Putin was greeted by Cai Qi, a member of the Chinese Communist Party's top leadership. A ceremonial guard and welcome event were also arranged for Putin, but the formality differed from the personal reception extended to Trump.


For Japan's Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi, a different scene unfolded. Although a red carpet was laid out, the scale of the reception was relatively modest. She was welcomed by Zhang Qi, a former Chinese ambassador to Greece, and there was no large crowd or performance as seen with other leaders. No separate summit with Xi Jinping was held.


Stalin's Cold Reception of Mao Zedong in 1948


One airport, three receptions.


The world sought to read how China was treating the U.S., Russia, and Japan through these scenes.


However, to understand the true meaning of protocol, one must return to Moscow 77 years ago.


In December 1949, just over two months after the establishment of the People's Republic of China, Mao Zedong visited the Soviet Union. Economic and military support from the Soviets was crucial for the fledgling China. Mao aimed to establish a new alliance with Joseph Stalin, the leader of the socialist bloc.


However, the reality in Moscow was harsh.


Stalin did not easily grant Mao, the victor of the Chinese revolution, an equal status with the Soviet Union. Negotiations were delayed, and Mao had to wait for a long time at his residence on the outskirts of Moscow. Although he was the top leader representing China, he was merely a junior leader in the hierarchy of the socialist bloc.


Mao was furious. He had come to Moscow not just for a congratulatory visit but to establish a new state relationship. He needed Soviet economic support and an alliance, but he also wanted recognition of China's independence and dignity.


In February 1950, the Sino-Soviet Treaty of Friendship, Alliance, and Mutual Assistance was signed. On the surface, it was a bond between two socialist powers. However, underlying it were Stalin's sense of superiority and Mao's deep dissatisfaction.


Protocol revealed the power differences between nations. And that memory lingered for a long time.


After Stalin's death, Nikita Khrushchev, who became the leader of the Soviet Union, sought to improve relations with China. However, conflicts between the two countries intensified. Disagreements over nuclear technology cooperation, military strategy, and socialist lines grew.


Khrushchev's Visit to China in 1958: Meetings by the Swimming Pool


In the summer of 1958, Khrushchev visited Beijing. Mao held talks around a swimming pool. The image of Mao enjoying swimming while Khrushchev, who was not accustomed to water, became a later symbol of Sino-Soviet conflict.


Historical research analyzing Soviet meeting records suggests that Mao used the informal setting of the swimming pool to make his counterpart uncomfortable. However, the two leaders also exchanged jokes during the talks. One scene cannot explain all diplomatic relations of that time.


Nevertheless, the historical significance is clear.


The Chinese leader, who felt poorly treated in Moscow, welcomed the Soviet leader in Beijing on his own terms. Protocol became a challenge to the hierarchy of power.


The Sino-Soviet conflict ultimately expanded into clashes over ideology, strategy, and national interests. The shared ideology of socialism did not prevent power competition between the nations.


In that gap, the world order shifted.


In 1972, U.S. President Richard Nixon's visit to China marked a turning point in Cold War history. Although the U.S. and China were ideologically hostile, they improved relations in the face of a common strategic variable: the Soviet Union.


At Beijing Airport, Premier Zhou Enlai welcomed Nixon. Their handshake became a symbol of a new era. It was not only because the U.S. and China recognized each other's systems but also because the realities of international politics led the two countries to cooperation.


Diplomacy is not about emotions. There are no eternal enemies or eternal friends. National interests and changes in the international order reshape relationships.


Half a century has passed.


The relationship between the U.S. and China has shifted from cooperation to competition. China has grown into a global economic powerhouse, and the U.S. has begun to perceive China's technological and military rise as a strategic challenge. Semiconductors, artificial intelligence, advanced manufacturing, supply chains, and security in the Taiwan Strait have become the center of competition.


2023 San Francisco APEC: U.S. Treasury Secretary Welcomes Xi Jinping


However, as competition deepens, dialogue between leaders becomes increasingly important.


During the APEC summit held in San Francisco in November 2023, U.S. President Joe Biden and Xi Jinping held a separate summit. When Xi arrived at the airport, he was welcomed by U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen and California Governor Gavin Newsom, while Biden greeted Xi at the summit venue.


The two countries sought to manage competition while restoring military communication and preventing a rapid deterioration of relations. While the formality of protocol was important, the more crucial aspect was establishing channels for dialogue to avoid conflict.


A different scene unfolded in Shenzhen in 2026.


Xi personally came to the airport to greet Trump. There were explanations that this was a response to the hospitality Trump showed during his previous visit to China. It sent a message that China values etiquette and reciprocates goodwill.


But is that sufficient explanation?


The U.S. is China's primary strategic competitor. American controls over advanced semiconductors and artificial intelligence technology are directly linked to China's industrial development. Trade, finance, and tensions in the Taiwan Strait can also shake the relationship between the two countries.


For China, it is necessary to manage its relationship with the U.S. stably. The special hospitality shown to Trump can be interpreted as a diplomatic means to express that need.


However, hospitality does not equate to submission. A hug does not signify the completion of reconciliation.


China aims to continue its competition with the U.S. while preventing it from escalating into uncontrollable conflict. The U.S. must also manage economic interests and military risks amid strategic competition with China.


That is the reality both countries face.


Protocol regarding Russia shows a different calculation.


Cai Qi, who welcomed President Putin, is a key figure in Chinese power. He is a close aide to Xi Jinping and a member of the Communist Party's top leadership. Therefore, it is hasty to interpret that Russia was treated coldly simply because Xi did not personally come to the airport.


China's relationship with Russia differs from its relationship with the U.S.


The two countries have strengthened strategic cooperation while sharing dissatisfaction with the U.S.-led international order. Cooperation in energy, military security, and international organizations is also a significant pillar. However, China's and Russia's interests do not always align.


China must maintain economic relations with the U.S. and Europe while cooperating with Russia. Russia, too, needs cooperation with China but must be cautious not to appear in a one-sided subordinate relationship.


At this APEC summit in Shenzhen, Xi, Trump, and Putin held a historic trilateral summit. The three leaders agreed on comprehensive principles, including dialogue to reduce nuclear risks. However, they did not establish specific goals or verification systems for nuclear disarmament.


The symbolism of the meeting was significant, but the practical outcomes were limited.


This reveals another function of protocol. While protocol can showcase the results of negotiations, it can also serve as a stage to imbue historical significance to negotiations that lack substantial outcomes.


Simply having the leaders of great powers sit together does not guarantee peace in the world.


Actions must follow to reduce nuclear weapons, lower the risk of war, and respect international law and national sovereignty.


Takaichi's Modest Reception Reflects 'Discomfort' Over Taiwan


How should we interpret China's protocol toward Japan?


When Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi arrived in China, she received a simpler reception than other major leaders. The scene of her disembarking from the aircraft, the movement route, and the scale of the welcoming crowd became points of comparison.


Some even questioned the arrangement of the aircraft's stairs. Concerns were raised about whether the structure of the stairs and the angle of filming were appropriate for a female prime minister wearing a skirt.


However, it is essential to draw a clear line here. It is unverified whether the height and shape of the stairs were intended as an insult or targeted at her gender. One should not conclude that this was China's intent without examining differences due to aircraft type, airport equipment, safety regulations, and filming locations.


Analysis of diplomacy must be meticulous. The moment suspicion is turned into fact, analysis becomes propaganda.


Even confirmed facts sufficiently explain the cooling of Japan-China relations.


Prime Minister Takaichi mentioned Japan's security and collective self-defense issues in the event of a Taiwan contingency, which drew strong backlash from China. China considers the Taiwan issue a core interest. Japan believes stability in the Taiwan Strait directly impacts its security.


This conflict is interpreted as reflected in the protocol at the Shenzhen APEC.


However, the Japanese government denied interpretations that China intentionally treated the prime minister coldly. Therefore, it is necessary to distinguish between confirming differences in protocol and affirming China's intent.


China's actions can be read as diplomatic pressure. However, it cannot be assumed that such pressure will necessarily benefit China. Excessive coldness can provoke domestic opinion in the counterpart country and further escalate conflicts.


In diplomacy, it is easy to damage the counterpart's face. Restoring damaged trust is difficult.


So What About South Korea, Which Received 'Hospitality'? Don't Jump to Conclusions of Diplomatic Victory


How should South Korea view this scene?


President Lee Jae-myung received hospitality from China at this APEC and held a summit with Xi Jinping. The improvement of South Korea-China relations is positive. If it can expand economic cooperation and secure a constructive role for China in peace on the Korean Peninsula, that would be even better.


However, South Korea should not assume it has achieved a diplomatic victory simply because China treated it warmly and Japan relatively coldly.


Although South Korea and Japan have a historically complex relationship, they are neighbors that must cooperate in security, advanced industries, supply chains, and culture. Improvement in relations with China should not lead to a deterioration in relations with Japan.


The alliance with the U.S. is also a crucial foundation for South Korea's security. Even if economic cooperation with China expands, trust in the alliance and principles of national security must not be shaken.


The goal of South Korean diplomacy is not to compete for the hospitality of great powers. It is to confidently cooperate with countries that have different interests while realizing our national interests.


This Shenzhen summit leaves another question.


When the leaders of the U.S., China, and Russia sit down to discuss the world order, where is South Korea?


At the Yalta Conference in 1945, the leaders of the U.S., the U.K., and the Soviet Union discussed major issues regarding post-war Europe and the international order. The reason that conference remains a symbol of great power politics today is that powerful nations made decisions that significantly impacted the future of other countries.


Of course, there is no basis to definitively label the 2026 Shenzhen meeting of the U.S., China, and Russia as a new Yalta Conference. There is no evidence that the fate of the Korean Peninsula was decided among these three countries.


However, the issues that need to be watched are clear.


We must prevent a situation where South Korea's voice and interests are marginalized in discussions about security on the Korean Peninsula and North Korea's nuclear issues.


Welcoming and Seeing Off Are Determined by the Counterpart, But We Must Create Our Own Place


The U.S., China, and Russia are all countries that significantly influence the Korean Peninsula. However, the most important parties determining peace and the future of the Korean Peninsula are South Korea and its residents.


The fate of a nation should not be determined by the hierarchy of protocol.


77 years ago, Mao Zedong experienced the coldness of great powers in Moscow. Today, China has become a country that expresses its diplomatic status and strategic intentions by welcoming world leaders.


History has changed. The relationships of power have also changed.


However, one fact remains unchanged: great powers move based on their interests.


Therefore, South Korea should ask not whose hospitality it received but what it gained. It should focus on what decisions were made in that position rather than where it sat. The achievements that impact the safety and lives of the people should be evaluated over the grandeur of hospitality.


Confucius said in the Analects that a gentleman achieves harmony without becoming identical. This principle is also necessary for South Korean diplomacy. While maintaining the alliance with the U.S., it should cooperate with China, open the future with Japan, and manage the possibility of dialogue with Russia. It should not unconditionally follow the wishes of any country but should uphold its principles while broadening the path of cooperation.


The dignity of diplomacy is revealed not in the scale of welcoming ceremonies but in a nation's pride, trust, and ability to create peace.


Welcoming and seeing off are determined by the counterpart. However, South Korea must create its own place.





* This article has been translated by AI.