Court Rejects Additional Search Warrant in Myungnyun-dang Embezzlement Case


The Serious Crimes Investigation Agency applied for a search warrant after uncovering additional allegations against Lee Jong-geun, the chairman of Myungnyun-dang, which operates the charcoal-grilled ribs franchise Myungnyun Jinsa Galbi, but the court rejected the request.

According to legal sources on the 22nd, the Antitrust Investigation Division of the Seoul Serious Crimes Investigation Agency, which is investigating allegations of unfair internal transactions involving Myungnyun-dang, recently recognized new allegations of embezzlement against the chairman and applied for a search warrant, but the court did not accept it.

The agency had previously had a warrant rejected at the prosecution stage and, after conducting supplementary investigations, reapplied for the warrant. The agency stated that a search was necessary to clarify the allegations based on established Supreme Court precedent, but the court determined that there was insufficient evidence at the initial investigation stage and rejected the warrant.

Earlier, on the 16th, the Antitrust Investigation Division of the Seoul Serious Crimes Investigation Agency conducted searches at 26 locations, including the Myungnyun-dang headquarters in Songpa-gu, Seoul, and the chairman's residence, on charges of violating the Fair Trade Act. This marked the agency's first compulsory investigation since its establishment 45 days prior and was the first case referred to the agency by the Fair Trade Commission, which holds exclusive reporting rights.

Myungnyun-dang is accused of unfairly supporting 14 loan companies owned by the chairman's family by lending a total of 298.3 billion won (KRW) at low interest rates of 2.3% to 4.6% over a period of four years and three months starting in December 2021, while those companies charged prospective franchisees high interest rates of 12% to 18% on loans, thus profiting from the interest.

In September, the Fair Trade Commission imposed a total fine of 14.87 billion won (KRW) on Myungnyun-dang and the loan companies and referred the case to the prosecution.

As the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency expanded its investigation to include embezzlement allegations against the chairman, some in the legal community have pointed out that the agency may have overstepped by attempting a separate investigation.

The Seoul Serious Crimes Investigation Agency explained in a press release that it applied for the warrant to clarify the allegations based on relevant crime evidence identified early in the investigation, according to Supreme Court precedent, and emphasized that the court rejected the application not due to a separate investigation but rather based on considerations of the level of evidence at the initial stage of the investigation, asserting that it is proceeding with the investigation in compliance with legal procedures.




* This article has been translated by AI.