Despite Expanded Parental Leave, Gaps Remain in Pay and Job Protection


A discussion was held to address the gaps in the parental leave system through recent court rulings and to explore improvement measures following system changes.

The Korean Women Lawyers Association and the Seoul Welfare Foundation's Social Welfare Public Law Center hosted a forum titled 'Current Realities and Challenges of the Parental Leave System' on November 13 in Seocho-gu, Seoul.

In her opening remarks, Chairwoman Heo Yoon-jung stated, "Workers continue to face difficulties from the application for parental leave to receiving benefits and performance evaluations upon returning to work," and emphasized the need to revise relevant laws and administrative guidelines to ensure that rights stipulated by law are protected in the workplace.

The first presenter, lawyer Baek Joo-won from the Seoul Welfare Foundation's Social Welfare Public Law Center, noted that while the use of split parental leave is increasing, the requirement for benefits to be paid only after using '30 days or more' has remained unchanged since its introduction in 2001.

Baek pointed out, "Although the parental leave benefit has required a minimum of 30 days since its inception, the exact reason for this requirement is unclear even in legislative documents," suggesting a need to reassess the payment criteria in light of the changing environment for parental leave usage.

He referenced a ruling from the Seoul Administrative Court this year, where a worker who took less than 30 days of initial parental leave and combined it with a second leave to reach 30 days was denied payment by the administrative agency, which cited the expiration of the application period after 12 months from the end of the first leave.

The court ruled that the right to claim benefits arises only when the total of both leaves reaches 30 days. Baek praised the ruling for effectively protecting the worker's right to receive benefits, stating, "The end date of the first parental leave does not constitute a day when rights have even begun to accrue, so the statute of limitations cannot be applied."

However, he cautioned that "the binding effect of the ruling is limited to the specific case," and stressed the need for revisions to administrative guidelines, as they impose excessive burdens on workers and lead to repeated consumption of litigation costs and administrative resources for agencies.

He also noted that while the newly introduced short parental leave allows for benefits after 7 days of use, the general parental leave still requires a minimum of 30 days. He proposed that the law be amended to allow benefits for general parental leave after 7 days of use as well.

The second presenter, lawyer Jeong Jeong-a from the Southwest Workplace Support Center for Working Mothers, suggested practical measures for the effective implementation of the parental leave system based on changes in the system and field consultation cases.

Jeong stated, "While the scope, pay, and duration of the parental leave system have consistently expanded over the past 38 years, the prohibitions against unfavorable treatment and the regulations for reinstatement have remained unchanged since the system's inception," adding that this is a primary reason for conflicts and disputes during usage.

In practice, gaps have been identified where workers in businesses with fewer than five employees are unable to file for unfair dismissal or face restrictions on their leave due to being contract workers. There have also been cases where they are assigned to newly created one-person teams or receive lower evaluations after returning.

Jeong emphasized that the regulations for unfair dismissal should apply to businesses with fewer than five employees in cases of maternity protection-related dismissals.

To prevent conflicts and disadvantages after returning from leave, she proposed that employers be required to establish and implement plans for substituting or reallocating workers' duties, and that they should be explicitly obligated to provide written explanations if evaluations or job roles are adversely changed within a certain period after the end of parental leave.

The forum included a designated discussion with seven participants from academia, labor, corporate HR, and government, based on the issues raised in the two presentations.

Professor Yoon Soo-jung from Kangwon National University Law School remarked on the Seoul Administrative Court ruling, stating, "It is significant that the ruling interpreted relevant regulations in line with the constitutional intent of maternal protection," but raised concerns about whether it is appropriate to penalize those who have not yet met the requirements for benefits simply for not applying in advance.

She expressed agreement with the proposal to relax the benefit requirement to 7 days but noted that determining the appropriateness of this period should consider actual demand and administrative costs.

Researcher Koo Mi-young from the Korean Women's Policy Institute concurred that workers in businesses with fewer than five employees face challenges in utilizing labor dispute resolution procedures when subjected to unfavorable treatment due to parental leave, advocating for amendments to the Equal Employment Opportunity Act to regulate such disadvantages.

She also pointed out that even with expanded legal grounds, the effectiveness of remedies is limited if affected workers do not recognize the illegality and secure evidence in a timely manner, highlighting the need for enhanced professional services from organizations like the Seoul Welfare Foundation and the Ministry of Employment and Labor's private employment equality counseling centers.

Professor Lee Jae-hoon from Hankuk University of Foreign Studies Law School noted the recent introduction of a non-application principle in the Basic Social Security Act and suggested that parental leave benefits could also include this principle. He explained, "If applicants, employers, and relevant authorities submit data that is systematically managed, the application of the non-application principle could be feasible."

Kim Moon-jeong, director of the Seoul Southwest Workplace Support Center for Working Mothers, shared a case where a franchise restaurant branch manager returned from parental leave but was assigned only simple tasks performed by new employees due to the absence of a branch manager position. She also mentioned instances where team leaders returning from parental leave faced reduced authority and salary due to being held accountable for team mistakes, proposing additional improvements such as the introduction of dedicated labor inspectors for maternal protection and the establishment of employment retention rate indicators after parental leave.




* This article has been translated by AI.