Internal divisions have emerged between the U.S. Commerce and Treasury Departments regarding export regulations on advanced artificial intelligence (AI) semiconductors to China during the Trump administration.
This discord was evident in the first line of a press release issued by the U.S. Commerce Department on November 16, which announced strengthened regulations on AI semiconductors for China.
The Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) under the Commerce Department stated that it would implement measures to control China's remote access to advanced AI semiconductors "in accordance with directives from the Treasury Department and the National Security Council (NSC)."
This action was taken to block a key route through which Chinese companies have been circumventing existing U.S. export controls by utilizing computing resources from overseas data centers.
Notably, while the announcement was made under the name of Jeffrey Kessler, the Assistant Secretary for Industry Security at the Commerce Department, it specified that the regulations were drafted by the Treasury Department and the White House NSC. On November 17, the South China Morning Post (SCMP) analyzed this as a case showing that proper coordination between departments regarding AI semiconductor export regulations was lacking.
Experts pointed out that the Commerce Department's unusual act of effectively shifting the responsibility for the regulation it announced to other departments indicates an attempt to evade accountability.
Christopher Padilla, former Assistant Secretary for International Trade at the U.S. Commerce Department, told SCMP, "In my 35 years of working in export controls, I have never seen anything like this. It is unprecedented for BIS to essentially deny responsibility for regulations issued in its name and legal authority."
He noted that typically, even when there are inter-departmental disagreements, the entire administration presents a unified voice after a policy decision is made, stating that this action shows "the Commerce Department is effectively protesting while announcing the regulation."
He further expressed concern that this suggests a breakdown in inter-departmental cooperation regarding export controls, sending conflicting messages to industry, allies, and China. He warned that revealing internal discord within the administration ahead of the U.S.-China summit is dangerous.
This controversy arose amid public conflicts between Secretary of Commerce Howard Rudnick and Secretary of the Treasury Scott Vesey.
Earlier, Secretary Vesey criticized the Commerce Department for delaying the inclusion of Megaspeed, a customer of NVIDIA, on the export control "Entity List" despite concerns that the company may have diverted advanced U.S. AI semiconductors to China.
Megaspeed is known to be associated with Alice Huang, who was an executive there and is reported to have had an affair with former NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang. U.S. intelligence agencies have suspected that Alice Huang may have engaged in espionage for the Chinese government. China has denied these allegations. The former CEO stepped down from his position on December 12 amid the controversy.
However, President Trump has shown support for Secretary Rudnick, stating that Rudnick's actions were intended to "prevent relations with China from deteriorating further."
On November 16, before embarking on a trip to Asia, President Trump explained that the conflict between the two secretaries stemmed from "different views," with one side seeking to maintain friendly relations with China while the other aims for confrontation. He added, "I understand both sides' positions."
Both Secretary Rudnick and Secretary Vesey are accompanying President Trump on his trip to the Philippines and China.
Meanwhile, the Chinese government has immediately reacted against this measure, warning of countermeasures. On November 17, during a regular briefing, the Chinese Foreign Ministry criticized the new U.S. regulations controlling remote access to advanced AI semiconductors by Chinese companies as "economic coercion" and an "exercise of extraterritorial jurisdiction." It stated, "China will take necessary measures to firmly safeguard its legitimate rights and interests."
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.