Debate Over Coordination in Special Prosecutor's Indictment of Former Coast Guard Officials


Kim Jong-wook, former head of the Korea Coast Guard, and Ahn Seong-sik, former planning and coordination officer, are contesting the indictment process by the second comprehensive special prosecutor team, led by Kwon Chang-young. They are demanding clarification on whether there was prior coordination with the insurrection special prosecutor team, which previously decided not to file charges against them. The legality of the indictment process is under scrutiny, particularly regarding adherence to established coordination procedures.

On November 3, the Criminal Division 38-3 of the Seoul Central District Court, presided over by judges Choi Young-gak, Jang Seong-jin, and Jeong Su-young, held the first trial for Kim and Ahn, who face charges of insurrection accomplice and abuse of authority. Both defendants denied all charges during the hearing, following a preparatory session last month.

Ahn's defense attorney argued, "If a different conclusion is reached from the previous special prosecutor, there must be coordination with them, but no documentation has been submitted to prove such coordination," claiming that the investigation and indictment procedures were unlawful.

According to Article 21, Section 3 of the comprehensive special prosecutor law, any decision that differs from the previous three major special prosecutors or could affect the maintenance of charges must involve prior consultation with the relevant special prosecutor.

Previously, the insurrection special prosecutor team conducted a search and summoned Ahn for questioning but ultimately decided not to file charges, citing insufficient evidence. Subsequently, the comprehensive special prosecutor team reopened the investigation and expanded it to include Kim, leading to their indictment on August 12.

On August 20, the insurrection special prosecutor team sent a letter to the comprehensive special prosecutor, urging compliance with legal regulations regarding Ahn's indictment, but reportedly did not receive a response.

Kim's defense team also requested confirmation on whether any coordination occurred, asserting that if it did, relevant documents should be submitted. They clarified that while they do not claim the absence of coordination constitutes a fundamental flaw warranting dismissal of charges, they argue that it indicates procedural deficiencies.

Ahn's defense contended that actions taken during the martial law period were part of emergency preparedness efforts, not insurrection involvement. They argued that merely discussing preparations for actions under the Chungmu Plan does not equate to insurrection. The attorney stated, "There must be sufficient explanation as to why preparing for an illegal martial law is considered insurrection."

The comprehensive special prosecutor team believes that the two defendants convened a nationwide video conference of commanders immediately after the declaration of martial law to arrange for the deployment of Coast Guard personnel to the joint investigation team and to provide detention facilities. They also view the dispatch of one Coast Guard officer as a government liaison to the Joint Chiefs of Staff as an act of insurrection.

Additionally, Ahn is accused of being involved in revising the 'martial law command organization plan,' which included automatic deployment of Coast Guard personnel, while exchanging classified documents with the Military Counterintelligence Command since 2023.




* This article has been translated by AI.