As uncertainty looms over the stock market, the performance of exchange-traded funds (ETFs) tracking indices from the Korea Exchange and FnGuide has shown a stark contrast. In sectors like semiconductors, ETFs following FnGuide indices experienced smaller declines, while those tracking exchange indices performed relatively well in securities and secondary batteries.
According to the Korea Exchange on November 4, Samsung Asset Management's 'KODEX Semiconductor' closed at 104,930 won, down 37,700 won (26.47%) from early last month. This product is a passive ETF that tracks the KRX Semiconductor Index, designed to yield returns similar to the underlying index by reflecting the composition and weight of its constituent stocks.
In contrast, NH Amundi Asset Management's Hana Fn K-Semiconductor ETF fell 22.82% during the same period. This ETF tracks the FnGuide K-Semiconductor Index, resulting in a decline that was 3.65 percentage points smaller than that of KODEX Semiconductor. Even among passive ETFs investing in the same domestic semiconductor sector, performance varied based on the index being tracked.
When comparing performance over the first half of the year, the gap becomes even more pronounced. The Hana Fn K-Semiconductor ETF rose 120.83% year-to-date, while the KODEX Semiconductor ETF increased by only 71.17%. Trading volume also favored the Hana Fn K-Semiconductor ETF, which recorded 808,784,431 shares traded, surpassing KODEX Semiconductor's 759,509,920 shares.
These differences stem from the design of each index. Index providers establish criteria for investment targets, stock selection, weightings, and periodic adjustment rules to calculate the indices. Asset management firms then choose these as underlying indices for their ETFs. In some cases, asset managers and index providers collaborate to develop customized indices, leading to variations in returns based on stock composition and weightings.
In the ongoing market correction that began last month, sector-specific ETF performances have diverged according to index design. On the previous day, the returns of 'KODEX Securities' and 'TIGER Secondary Battery TOP10,' which track exchange-calculated indices, were 0.35 and 0.89 percentage points higher, respectively, than those of 'TIGER Securities' and 'KODEX Secondary Battery Industry,' which follow FnGuide indices. Conversely, in the gaming sector, the decline of 'KODEX Gaming Industry,' which tracks the FnGuide index, was 0.41 percentage points smaller than that of 'TIGER Gaming TOP10.'
When comparing year-to-date returns, the gap widened further. The TIGER Secondary Battery TOP10, which tracks the exchange index, rose 9.23%, while the KODEX Secondary Battery Industry ETF, following the FnGuide index, fell 0.33%, resulting in a 9.56 percentage point difference. The KODEX Securities, tracking the exchange index, declined by 3.91%, while the TIGER Securities, following the FnGuide index, dropped by 5.42%, leading to a return difference of 1.51 percentage points.
According to the Korea Exchange on November 4, Samsung Asset Management's 'KODEX Semiconductor' closed at 104,930 won, down 37,700 won (26.47%) from early last month. This product is a passive ETF that tracks the KRX Semiconductor Index, designed to yield returns similar to the underlying index by reflecting the composition and weight of its constituent stocks.
In contrast, NH Amundi Asset Management's Hana Fn K-Semiconductor ETF fell 22.82% during the same period. This ETF tracks the FnGuide K-Semiconductor Index, resulting in a decline that was 3.65 percentage points smaller than that of KODEX Semiconductor. Even among passive ETFs investing in the same domestic semiconductor sector, performance varied based on the index being tracked.
When comparing performance over the first half of the year, the gap becomes even more pronounced. The Hana Fn K-Semiconductor ETF rose 120.83% year-to-date, while the KODEX Semiconductor ETF increased by only 71.17%. Trading volume also favored the Hana Fn K-Semiconductor ETF, which recorded 808,784,431 shares traded, surpassing KODEX Semiconductor's 759,509,920 shares.
These differences stem from the design of each index. Index providers establish criteria for investment targets, stock selection, weightings, and periodic adjustment rules to calculate the indices. Asset management firms then choose these as underlying indices for their ETFs. In some cases, asset managers and index providers collaborate to develop customized indices, leading to variations in returns based on stock composition and weightings.
In the ongoing market correction that began last month, sector-specific ETF performances have diverged according to index design. On the previous day, the returns of 'KODEX Securities' and 'TIGER Secondary Battery TOP10,' which track exchange-calculated indices, were 0.35 and 0.89 percentage points higher, respectively, than those of 'TIGER Securities' and 'KODEX Secondary Battery Industry,' which follow FnGuide indices. Conversely, in the gaming sector, the decline of 'KODEX Gaming Industry,' which tracks the FnGuide index, was 0.41 percentage points smaller than that of 'TIGER Gaming TOP10.'
When comparing year-to-date returns, the gap widened further. The TIGER Secondary Battery TOP10, which tracks the exchange index, rose 9.23%, while the KODEX Secondary Battery Industry ETF, following the FnGuide index, fell 0.33%, resulting in a 9.56 percentage point difference. The KODEX Securities, tracking the exchange index, declined by 3.91%, while the TIGER Securities, following the FnGuide index, dropped by 5.42%, leading to a return difference of 1.51 percentage points.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.