Korea Gas Corporation's compensation for defects in the cargo tanks of domestically produced liquefied natural gas (LNG) carriers has increased to approximately 260 billion won following an appeals court ruling.
According to Yonhap News Agency, the Seoul High Court's Civil Division 37-1, presided over by Judges Kim Jong-ki, Min Jeong-seok, and Park Eun-young, ruled on November 11 that SK Shipping must receive 220.39 billion won in damages from Korea Gas Corporation. The court also ordered Korea Gas Corporation to pay 48.07 billion won to Samsung Heavy Industries in a separate lawsuit.
In the first trial, the court had ordered Korea Gas Corporation to pay 115.4 billion won to SK Shipping and 72.6 billion won to Samsung Heavy Industries. In the appeals court, SK Shipping's compensation increased by about 105 billion won, while Samsung Heavy Industries' compensation decreased by approximately 24.5 billion won. The total compensation amount for both companies is now 268.46 billion won.
The court stated, "A significant defect known as a cold spot has occurred, which can lead to sudden brittle fracture of the vessel's structure," reaffirming its earlier judgment.
It added, "Due to the cold spot defect, the vessel in question is unable to operate as an LNG carrier under the transportation contract," and noted that the defendant is liable for damages caused by moisture and plywood cracking in the cargo tank due to a breach of duty of care.
Korea Gas Corporation also lost a separate lawsuit against SK Shipping. The court found that Korea Gas Corporation's negligence contributed to the suspension of vessel operations, and therefore it could not hold SK Shipping liable for failing to deploy a substitute vessel.
The dispute originated from the domestically developed LNG cargo tank technology known as 'KC-1.' The government invested 19.7 billion won over ten years starting in 2004 to reduce reliance on foreign technology. Korea Gas Corporation and KCL LNG Tech were responsible for the technology development, while domestic shipbuilders, including Samsung Heavy Industries, participated in constructing the vessels.
Samsung Heavy Industries built the LNG carriers SK Serenity and SK Spica using the KC-1 technology and delivered them to SK Shipping in 2018. However, both vessels ceased operations just five months after delivery due to issues such as the cold spot phenomenon, where parts of the hull dropped below the allowable minimum temperature.
Subsequently, Samsung Heavy Industries and SK Shipping filed lawsuits against Korea Gas Corporation in 2019, seeking compensation for repair costs and losses incurred due to the suspension of operations.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.