Korea Zinc and Youngpoong MBK Clash Over Shareholder Meeting Ruling

Korea Zinc and Youngpoong MBK Partners continue to clash over the first-instance ruling regarding the cancellation of last year's regular shareholder meeting resolutions. Youngpoong and MBK have claimed accountability for Korea Zinc's management based on the ruling, while Korea Zinc has countered that the opposing side is misinterpreting the court's findings.


According to industry sources on November 16, the Seoul Central District Court's Civil Division 29 ruled on November 12 in favor of Youngpoong and MBK in their lawsuit against Korea Zinc seeking to annul the shareholder meeting resolutions.


The court explained, "Korea Zinc cannot restrict the voting rights of existing shareholders by applying mutual share provisions for management rights defense." Consequently, it ordered the annulment of key resolutions, including amendments to the articles of incorporation and the appointment of directors and audit committee members, passed at the regular shareholder meeting in March of last year.


In a statement, Youngpoong and MBK asserted that the ruling confirmed the illegality and unfairness of actions taken by Korea Zinc Chairman Choi Yoon-beom to limit voting rights.


They particularly emphasized that the court deemed the acquisition of Youngpoong shares by Korea Zinc's overseas subsidiary, Sun Metal Corporation (SMC), and the in-kind dividend to its subsidiary, Sun Metal Holdings (SMH), as private misappropriation of company assets and a violation of the directors' duty of loyalty.


They also raised concerns about the process of restricting voting rights on the day of the shareholder meeting. According to Youngpoong and MBK, SMH increased its stake in Youngpoong by purchasing an additional 1,350 shares just before the regular shareholder meeting on March 28, raising its ownership to 10.03%. The meeting, originally scheduled for 9 a.m., was delayed until 11:32 a.m.


Youngpoong and MBK claimed that during this process, Korea Zinc's management improperly exercised the authority of the subsidiary's board and the conduct of the shareholder meeting. They called for responsible actions from Chairman Choi and urged the Fair Trade Commission to review the related matters.


In contrast, Korea Zinc rebutted that Youngpoong and MBK are misrepresenting the plaintiffs' claims as the court's judgment. They argue that the opposing side is exaggerating parts of the ruling to continue their offensive against the management.


Korea Zinc contended that the first-instance ruling contradicts existing Supreme Court precedents and the Supreme Court's judgment on the mutual share voting rights injunction case. Earlier in April, the Supreme Court dismissed Youngpoong's appeal in that injunction case.


Korea Zinc maintains that there are no newly revealed facts in the main lawsuit following the injunction case. They plan to contest the legal validity of the mutual share voting rights restriction in the appellate court.


A Korea Zinc official stated, "Korea Zinc will firmly respond to the dissemination of distorted claims and will strive to safeguard the economic security of South Korea, stabilize the supply chain of critical minerals, and enhance corporate value."


The conflict between the two sides began in September 2024 when Youngpoong and MBK sought to secure management control of Korea Zinc. Since then, legal disputes over mutual share voting rights restrictions, shareholder meeting resolutions, and board composition have continued.


The ruling to annul the shareholder meeting resolutions is still at the first-instance stage. With Korea Zinc announcing plans to appeal, the legal battle over the legality of mutual share voting rights restrictions and the effectiveness of last year's regular shareholder meeting resolutions is expected to continue in higher courts.





* This article has been translated by AI.