Homeplus Faces Extended Business Disruption as Competition Intensifies


As Homeplus's business disruption continues, the growth of competing large discount stores such as E-Mart and Lotte Mart, as well as corporate supermarkets (SSM), has become prominent. Amid financial difficulties and a potential reclosure, competing large discount stores have improved their performance due to increased customer traffic, while SSM is focusing on securing shopping demand with fresh produce and fast delivery.
 
According to the retail industry on the 16th, Homeplus, which is undergoing corporate rehabilitation, has not been able to escape from supply chain issues and poor sales since resuming operations in August. Homeplus's recent daily sales have fallen below 3 billion won (KRW), and the volume of product purchases has reportedly decreased by about 30% compared to the initial reopening period. Due to a lack of operating funds, the possibility of reclosure of all stores this month has been mentioned.
 
The decline in sales is also evident. According to Mobile Index, Homeplus's estimated card payment amount dropped from 98.2 billion won (KRW) between August 11 and September 10 to 64.9 billion won (KRW) between October 11 and November 10, a decrease of about 34%. Although Homeplus has secured over 4,500 types of fresh produce and daily necessities for discounts since the 12th, it is still struggling with supply chain issues and customer recovery.
 
In the midst of Homeplus's operational disruption, competing large discount stores have improved their performance. E-Mart's discount store operating profit for the third quarter was 90.8 billion won (KRW), a 63.6% increase compared to the same period last year. Same-store sales increased by 10.6%, and the visitor growth rate rose from 0.7% in the first half to 5.3% in the third quarter.
 
Lotte Mart's domestic business also saw operating profit surge to 17.9 billion won (KRW), a 725.5% increase. The same-store sales growth rate reached 18%. This is interpreted as a combination of factors including the timing difference of the Chuseok holiday, the base effect of consumer coupons, and reduced competition due to Homeplus's operational disruption.
 
In fact, an increase in sales at competing stores near Homeplus has been confirmed. Sales at E-Mart's Yeongdeungpo and Dunsan stores, located within 3 kilometers of Homeplus, increased by 22% and 19%, respectively, in the third quarter. Lotte Mart is also analyzed to have benefited from the operational gap of Homeplus. According to Mirae Asset Securities, Lotte Mart store sales in areas competing with Homeplus increased by 4-5% in the second quarter, while sales in non-competing areas decreased by 2%.
 
Lee Jin-hyup, a researcher at Hanwha Investment & Securities, stated, "The situation for Homeplus is worsening again," and predicted, "E-Mart will be able to absorb the demand of consumers looking for cheaper products due to consumption polarization by lowering prices based on its overwhelming bulk purchasing power."
 
SSM is also continuing its growth trend. GS The Fresh's third-quarter sales reached 527.7 billion won (KRW), a 14.9% increase, and its operating profit rose to 23.9 billion won (KRW), a 159.8% increase. E-Mart Everyday and Lotte Super also saw their operating profits increase to 11 billion won (KRW) and 5.7 billion won (KRW), respectively, compared to the same period last year.
 
The growth drivers for SSM are proximity delivery and fresh produce. GS The Fresh's third-quarter quick commerce sales increased by 52.2%, and its share of total sales expanded to 10.1%. E-Mart Everyday's quick commerce sales also rose by 38.5%.
 
An industry insider remarked, "The longer Homeplus's normalization of operations is delayed, the greater the opportunity for competing large discount stores to secure new customers will be," adding, "The key is how many temporarily attracted customers can be retained as regular customers."




* This article has been translated by AI.