Foreign Investors Watch South Korean Stock Market Amid Compliance Challenges

Foreign investors are closely monitoring the South Korean stock market, but challenges related to internal policies and compliance burdens have hindered their active shareholder engagement. While they positively assess the improvement of corporate governance and the expansion of shareholder returns in South Korea, analysts suggest that the extent to which reform measures are implemented in actual corporate settings will influence foreign investors' participation. The upcoming annual general meeting next year is seen as a test for these reforms, with expectations for more substantial changes starting in 2028.


Ryan Albert, CEO of Turtone Capital, stated during a press conference held at the FKI Tower in Yeouido, Seoul, on November 17, "Many investors are keeping a close eye on the South Korean market, but they are unable to voice their opinions due to internal policies." He explained that while foreign investors are attracted to the undervaluation of the South Korean market and the potential for governance improvements, there are practical barriers that must be overcome before they can engage in public shareholder activities.


Turtone Capital is a U.S. investment firm that focuses on long-term investments in publicly traded companies in the Asia-Pacific region, particularly South Korea. The firm prioritizes the potential for enhancing corporate and shareholder value and engages with management and boards to communicate its views. It has invested in over ten domestic companies and has recently conducted public shareholder engagement activities with Golfzon Holdings and Orion.


Albert, who played baseball during his college years, assessed that South Korea's value-up reforms are currently at the "second or third inning" of a baseball game. He indicated that if the introduction of the system represents the first inning, the country has now entered the phase of applying these reforms in actual corporate settings. He elaborated, "In the fourth to sixth innings, various additional reform proposals will be introduced, and the process of implementing these reforms and generating results will extend into the seventh and eighth innings."


He cited internal approvals and compliance procedures as reasons why foreign investors find it difficult to engage in public shareholder activities. Albert noted, "To take public actions or send letters, significant efforts are required from a compliance perspective, especially for foreign funds." He explained that funds must prepare their internal policies and procedures before sending letters requesting improvements from the companies they invest in or raising issues publicly, and many funds are not yet adequately prepared for this.


He also mentioned the operational burdens associated with exercising voting rights in South Korea. "To invest and exercise voting rights in Korea, there are requirements to hold cash within the country," he said. "While the technical aspects do not play a significant role, the need for additional efforts to take voting actions or public measures could be a contributing factor."


In this context, Albert highlighted the 2027 annual general meeting as a critical test for the implementation of value-up reforms. He stated, "We need to observe the situation after the 2027 annual general meeting, where various reform measures will be put to the test. I believe we could see more substantial changes by 2028." However, he warned that if the value-up reform measures are not properly implemented or regress, it could hinder the influx of foreign investors. He remarked, "If the reform measures do not gain momentum and regress, that would be the most concerning aspect for the influx of foreign investors," and expressed his intention to closely monitor the upcoming annual meeting season.


Regarding the speed of South Korea's value-up initiatives, he assessed that the country has made faster progress compared to Japan. Albert stated, "I believe South Korea has achieved changes in the past two and a half years that took Japan over ten years to accomplish." However, he noted that additional institutional improvements are necessary, considering the differences in corporate governance between the two countries. In South Korea, it is common for controlling shareholders to exercise management rights with ownership stakes of 20-40%, whereas this proportion is relatively lower in Japan. He emphasized, "Minority shareholders should also receive treatment comparable to that of controlling shareholders."


Albert identified the governance structure and decision-making processes of controlling shareholders as causes of the undervaluation of the South Korean stock market. He pointed out, "In many listed companies, the founding families hold 20-40% of the shares while managing the companies as if they owned all the shares." He argued that the burden of inheritance and gift taxes may incentivize keeping stock prices low rather than raising them. He noted, "There are often cases where the pressure of inheritance or gift taxes leads to keeping stock prices low rather than maximizing shareholder value by raising prices."


He also linked the low return on equity (ROE) to governance issues. Albert remarked, "Over the past 20 years, the ROE of the South Korean stock market has been around 7%." He stated that while corporate governance is not the sole reason, it is a significant contributing factor. He added that the recent volatility in the stock market has also been influenced by the market structure, where the market capitalization of semiconductor-related companies like Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix exceeds 50%.


Regarding discussions on the introduction of mandatory tender offers, he did not definitively state whether the purchase range should be set at 50% + 1 share or 100%, including the controlling shareholder's stake. However, he expressed that if the 50% + 1 share method is adopted, a proportional distribution of the purchase quantity based on each shareholder's ownership stake would be fair. He emphasized the need to ensure equity among shareholders during the design process of the system rather than supporting a specific purchase range.


Additionally, he called for the protection of minority shareholders, stating that the public offering price for Golfzon Holdings did not adequately reflect the company's value. He raised issues regarding capital allocation related to Orion's acquisition of JoongAng Ilbo and mentioned that Dong-A Pharmaceutical is considering appointing outside directors with expertise in consumer brands or asset allocation.


On the same day, Albert indicated that Turtone Capital is open to establishing a local presence while continuing its investments in the South Korean market. He stated, "We could consider opening a local office sooner rather than later," and expressed a positive outlook on establishing a South Korean office. However, he added that at this point, the focus would be on realizing the value of the invested companies and ensuring they receive fair evaluations in the market.





* This article has been translated by AI.