Special Counsel Seeks One-Year Prison Sentence for Former Defense Ministry Legal Officer Hong Chang-sik


Former Defense Ministry legal officer Hong Chang-sik has been sentenced to one year in prison for failing to provide necessary legal advice to the Minister and Vice Minister during the martial law declared on December 3.
 
The second comprehensive special counsel team, led by Special Counsel Kwon Chang-young, requested this sentence during the final hearing of Hong's dereliction of duty case at the Seoul Central District Court's Criminal Division 32, presided over by Judge Ryu Kyung-jin, on the 17th.

The special counsel pointed out that Hong had opportunities to express concerns while being in the same space as the Minister and Vice Minister but failed to assist them. They emphasized, "If appropriate punishment is not imposed on the defendant, it could set a bad precedent in history, allowing legal officers to remain silent in the face of unconstitutional and illegal exercises of public power or insurrection crimes."
 
The special counsel also mentioned that changing the legal officer's position to an open one was intended to strengthen judicial control over the military, stating that if the legal officer's assistance does not function in a crisis, safety mechanisms could be rendered ineffective.
 
In his final argument, Hong's defense claimed his innocence. The lawyer stated, "During the martial law, legal advisors and military judges from various units were also observing the situation," and questioned, "If we hold him accountable for not fulfilling his role based on post-evaluations, can the military prosecutors currently in court be free from that responsibility?"

Additionally, while expressing regret for not identifying the unconstitutional and illegal aspects more quickly and acting proactively, he argued that the responsibility for inappropriate and passive actions should be distinguished from the criminal charge of dereliction of duty.
 
In his final statement, Hong read a written statement, saying, "As a public official, I apologize to the people for failing to prevent the illegal martial law." He expressed, "I was so shocked by the term martial law that my mind went blank, and I was at a loss at that time. I believe I could prevent it now, but at that time, I could not at all."

He further argued, "The department responsible for martial law operations is separate within the Defense Ministry. I think it is excessive to hold me accountable solely because I am a lawyer without questioning the responsible department's personnel."
 
The sentencing for Hong is scheduled for 2 PM on December 22.
 
Meanwhile, the special counsel faced criticism from the court again regarding the opinion document. The court stated that the special counsel had included some evidence in the opinion document without proper citation, saying, "This is not a civil lawsuit, but a criminal lawsuit, and you cannot carelessly include evidence not adopted in court in the opinion document."

Previously, on the 12th, the court handling the case of former Capital Defense Command's 1st Security Division Chief Cho Sung-hyun ordered the special counsel to return and dispose of documents that included statements not agreed upon by the defense attorney.




* This article has been translated by AI.