Insurance premiums for Chinese automaker BYD, which have an accident claim rate more than 1.5 times higher than domestic electric vehicles, are surprisingly lower by hundreds of thousands of won. This discrepancy raises questions about the fairness of car insurance pricing, as drivers of domestic electric vehicles may be shouldering relatively higher premiums due to inadequate reflection of individual vehicle claim rates in the pricing.
According to the insurance industry on the 16th, A Insurance calculated car insurance estimates under the same subscription conditions, revealing that the annual insurance premium for the Tesla Model Y is 2.86 million won, the Hyundai Ioniq 5 is 2.84 million won, the Kia EV6 is 2.31 million won, and the BYD Sea Lion 7 is 2.18 million won. The premium for the Sea Lion 7 is 660,000 won lower than that of the Ioniq 5 and over 130,000 won cheaper than the EV6.
In contrast, the liability claim rate, which indicates the burden of insurance payouts due to accidents, shows a starkly different picture. BYD's average claim rate stands at 168%, which is 1.5 times higher than the average for domestic electric vehicles (110%) and 1.6 times higher than the average for imported electric vehicles (103%). Among specific models, the Dolphin has the highest rate at 185.5%, followed by the Sea Lion 7 at 184.9% and the Seal at 174.8%.
Tesla also exhibits a disparity between repair costs and actual insurance premiums. According to the Insurance Development Institute's vehicle model ratings, the Tesla Model Y is rated at level 8, which is lower than the Hyundai Ioniq 5 and Kia EV6, both rated at level 16. The vehicle model rating reflects the extent of damage and repair ease in accidents; a lower rating results in higher premiums for collision coverage.
In fact, the average insurance repair cost per incident for Tesla is 3.01 million won, nearly double that of Hyundai (1.51 million won) and Kia (1.44 million won). However, the annual insurance premium difference between the Model Y and the Ioniq 5 is only 12,110 won. Considering that the vehicle value of the Model Y is 66.99 million won, which is 12.49 million won higher than the Ioniq 5 (54.5 million won), the disparity in repair costs and vehicle prices does not distinctly reflect in the overall insurance premiums.
The insurance industry cites the insufficient accumulation of accident statistics for imported electric vehicles as one reason for this issue. Both Tesla and BYD have fewer domestic vehicles on the road compared to domestic brands, making it challenging to reliably calculate claim rates by vehicle type. Additionally, the application methods of the vehicle model ratings by the Insurance Development Institute can vary by insurance company, leading to differences in how these ratings are reflected in actual premiums.
The problem lies in the fact that these differences in claim rates are not adequately reflected in actual insurance premiums. Drivers of vehicles with long-term low claim rates end up paying higher premiums, while drivers of vehicles with high claim rates pay lower premiums, inevitably sparking controversy over the rationality of premium pricing.
As the entry of Chinese electric vehicles into the domestic market is expected to expand in the future, there are calls for a more sophisticated statistical and risk assessment system to be established for premium calculations. It is necessary to continuously accumulate data on accident history, actual repair costs, and parts procurement costs for new brands to reflect in insurance premiums.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.