Egyptian Anti-Government Protester Loses Asylum Case, Supreme Court Orders Rehearing


The Supreme Court overturned a lower court's ruling that denied asylum to an Egyptian national who claimed he was sentenced to a lengthy prison term for participating in anti-government protests in Egypt, citing the inability to verify the authenticity of the court documents.
 
According to legal sources on November 18, the Supreme Court's first division, led by Justice Cheon Dae-yeop, annulled the lower court's ruling that dismissed the asylum application of a 32-year-old Egyptian national, referred to as A, against the Incheon Immigration and Foreign Affairs Office, and sent the case back to the Seoul High Court.
 
A arrived at Incheon International Airport in July 2018 on a tourist visa (B-2) and applied for asylum a week later. He claimed he was arrested and tortured for participating in anti-government protests in Egypt and was sentenced to 15 years and 3 years in prison by local courts.

However, immigration authorities issued a denial of his asylum application in February 2022, stating that there was insufficient evidence to recognize a well-founded fear of persecution. The lower courts upheld this decision, stating they could not recognize the authenticity of the Egyptian court documents submitted by A.
 
The Supreme Court's ruling differed. The court noted that the judgment documents contained allegations, applicable laws, evidence summaries, and the defendant's claims without contradictions, and that the case number matched the indictment. It also pointed out that the names of the presiding judge, military prosecutor, and court clerk were included. The court referenced that the judgment could be verified on the 'Justice Watch Archive' site operated by an international human rights organization.
 
The court also considered that the Egyptian government had requested formal diplomatic channels to inquire about the case in February 2022, making it difficult to verify the authenticity through the embassy.

In this context, the court suggested that unless there are special circumstances to suspect falsehood in the process of being listed on the site, it could be considered as one of the grounds for recognizing the authenticity of the judgment documents.
 
The court concluded that the judgment documents were similar in format to those of other Egyptians recognized as refugees, were not fabricated, and that A obtained them through an Egyptian lawyer, indicating a significant likelihood that they were prepared by officials of the Egyptian judiciary in the course of their duties. The court pointed out that the lower court misunderstood the legal principles regarding the authenticity of foreign public documents and failed to conduct necessary hearings.




* This article has been translated by AI.