The cheating scandal involving the top scorer of this year's 63rd tax accountant qualification exam has been confirmed as a comprehensive disaster caused by the authorities' fixation on specific devices and inadequate on-site manuals. The Korea Industrial Human Resources Corporation (KIHRC), which oversees the exam, distributed a photo manual to catch 'artificial intelligence (AI) smart glasses,' but the top scorer actually modified a legally placed 'calculator' on the desk to function as a transmitter throughout the exam.
According to exclusive documents obtained by Aju Economy from the office of People Power Party lawmaker Park Soo-min on November 18, the manual for checking calculators used in the first and second tax accountant exams was grossly inadequate for detecting cheating involving advanced devices.
Both the first and second tax accountant exams allow the use of calculators. On exam day, communication devices such as smartphones must be turned off and stored in bags under the chairs, but calculators are permitted to remain on the desk throughout the exam as long as only necessary items are present.
According to materials submitted by KIHRC to the National Assembly, the corporation distributed 'training materials related to smart glasses' extensively across 20 exam sites and 361 exam rooms ahead of the second exam in July. This manual included front and side photos of popular smart glasses models such as Meta Ray-Ban, Meta Oakley, and Sears Lab (Alnoon), with blue borders marking the camera lens positions. Supervisors were instructed to focus on monitoring specific abnormal behaviors, such as continuous touching of the glasses' arms.
While KIHRC's surveillance was directed at 'smart glasses,' the item used by top scorer A (34) as the core 'transmitter' was not glasses but a 'calculator.' Although communication devices like smartphones were strictly controlled to be turned off and stored, calculators could be placed on the desk throughout the exam, which was exploited.
A used a miniature camera to take pictures of the questions and then transmitted them to a smartphone AI through the modified calculator, receiving answers on a small monitor.
Despite the calculator becoming a meticulous tool for the crime, the on-site inspection manual was merely superficial. According to the Q-Net guidance and implementation plan, the only regulation stated that 'calculators with data storage functions, such as engineering and financial calculators, must have their memory (including SD cards) removed or deleted (reset, initialized) by the examinee, and they must cooperate with the examiners to confirm the initialization.'
The problem is that even this was difficult to verify properly on-site. The inspection items in the supervisor's work guidelines included only 'confirmation of calculator reset (removal of case and SD card, checking for cheating scribbles).' There was no procedure in the manual to check the most critical aspects, such as whether the calculator had been modified or whether it contained shooting and communication functions.
Moreover, the time allocated for checking the examinee's belongings and the calculator reset status was merely 'one minute of waiting.' With two supervisors tasked with quickly reviewing the devices of about 20 examinees in just one minute, a thorough inspection was practically impossible.
Even more perplexingly, during the second exam (July 18), an inexplicable exception was introduced that actually relaxed controls compared to the first exam. While the first exam explicitly required 'removal of the case and SD card,' the second exam's work guidelines added a new exception stating, 'While the calculator cover should be removed, if the examinee wishes to use the cover, it may be allowed after the supervisor checks for any abnormalities.'
The results were disastrous. Top scorer A passed both the first and second exams, but the number of cheating detection and suspicion reports for both exams was 'zero.' The special report and supervisor logs indicated 'no issues' were reported.
The post-verification stage was also unprotected. KIHRC operates a 'successful candidate review committee' to check computer logic, but there is no systematic mechanism in place to separately review and cross-verify the answers of abnormally high scorers like the top scorer.
Ultimately, the corporation hastily reported the examinee to the police only after a video of the top scorer's confession spread and over 100 complaints urging an investigation were filed.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.