Ministry of Land Loses Appeal on Saemangeum Airport Plan Due to Inadequate Bird Strike Risk Assessment


The court's ruling that the basic plan for the Saemangeum International Airport development project must be canceled has been upheld in the appeal.

On November 18, the Seoul High Court Administrative Division 4-2 (Judges Lee Kwang-man, Moon Kwang-seob, Park Yeon-wook) ruled in favor of 1,296 citizens, including environmental groups, who filed a lawsuit against the Minister of Land, Infrastructure and Transport to cancel the basic plan for the Saemangeum International Airport development project, granting partial victory to the plaintiffs, just as in the first trial. The court dismissed all appeals from the Ministry of Land.

Similar to the first trial, the court recognized standing only for three plaintiffs who were acknowledged as residents of noise mitigation areas under the Airport Noise Prevention Act, dismissing the claims of the remaining plaintiffs.

The defendants, including the Jeonbuk Special Self-Governing Province and Korea Airports Corporation, argued that they could not seek cancellation of the plan due to environmental benefits unrelated to noise, but this was not accepted. The court stated that, according to Supreme Court precedents, if it relates to the legal interests of the plaintiffs, it can review all legal grounds for the illegality of the plan itself.

Regarding the key issue of bird strike risk assessment, the court pointed out that the Ministry of Land did not thoroughly examine this from the site selection stage. The court stated, "The public interest related to development presupposes the safe operation of the airport," adding, "Bird strikes can cause significant harm to many lives, bodies, and property from a single accident, making aviation safety a particularly important public interest to consider in airport site selection."

According to the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) manuals and announcements from the Ministry of Land, bird strike risks must be assessed in advance and mitigation measures established during airport site selection. However, the court found that the feasibility study process, which narrowed down 13 candidate sites, did not reflect any bird risk factors.

Additionally, the court noted that despite the Saemangeum site showing a significantly higher bird strike risk compared to other domestic airports, the Ministry of Land limited the assessment range to 5 kilometers and concluded that the risk was low based solely on the operational experience of the nearby Gunsan Airport.

The court also determined that the potential adverse effects on nearby migratory bird habitats, such as the UNESCO World Natural Heritage site of Seocheon Tidal Flat, located 7 kilometers away, and the habitats of over 31 legally protected species, were not adequately considered.

The Ministry of Land plans to carefully review the ruling before deciding whether to appeal.

The Saemangeum International Airport project aims to construct runways and passenger and cargo terminals on a 3.4 million square meter site in the Saemangeum area of Jeonbuk, with a target completion date in 2028.

After the Ministry of Land announced the basic plan in June 2022, civic groups filed a cancellation lawsuit in September of the same year, citing inadequate environmental assessments. The first trial court, held in September of last year, also ruled to cancel the basic plan due to insufficient bird strike risk assessment and flaws in the weighing of benefits.




* This article has been translated by AI.