Government launched the 'Salary Defense Force' on the 13th. This inter-agency task force aims to reduce living costs for workers and increase disposable income. Few would oppose the intention. However, discussions have already shifted towards tax cuts. Terms like 'sticky wallet' and 'hidden tax increase' are resurfacing, and proposals for an income tax inflation linkage system and various deductions are being mentioned as solutions. The belief is that cutting income tax is necessary to protect salaries. But is that really the case? Before prescribing a solution, we should first examine the diagnosis.
The rationale for tax reduction is based on tax revenue. Income tax revenue has increased from 27 trillion won (KRW) to 68 trillion won (KRW) over the past decade. However, just because tax revenue has increased does not mean that each individual's tax burden has become heavier. Tax revenue increases even when more people work or salaries rise. We also need to consider who is paying more. According to the National Assembly Budget Office, 84% of the increase in income tax over the past nine years since 2014 has come from workers earning over 80 million won (KRW) annually. This is a result of a growing number of high-income earners, not a surge in taxes for the average worker. The rising proportion of income tax within national tax revenue is also largely due to a decrease in corporate tax. In the coming year, when corporate tax is expected to rise significantly, even if income tax collections increase, its proportion will likely decrease.
So how much has the tax burden changed for the same individuals? Tax revenue statistics provide an incomplete answer because they aggregate different individuals each year. Therefore, I analyzed data from the Financial Panel, which surveys the same individuals annually. By tracking about 4,000 workers with total salaries under 100 million won (KRW) from 2009 over 14 years, more accurate information can be obtained. According to the data, their effective tax rate has risen by 2.7 percentage points. Of this increase, 80% is due to salaries rising faster than inflation. In fact, those whose salaries decreased saw their effective tax rates drop. It is difficult to claim that the increase in tax burden is significant when it is primarily due to increased income leading to higher taxes. Among the increase in tax burden experienced by the same individuals, only one-fifth is attributable to tax law changes.
The 0.55 percentage point increase in effective tax rate corresponding to this one-fifth should not be taken lightly. Even with salaries rising only in line with inflation, the tax base and deduction amounts remain unchanged, leading to higher taxes. This burden primarily falls on middle-income workers, lending credence to claims of hidden tax increases. However, one point needs to be clarified here: it is not just the fact that taxes are rising, but how low they are to begin with.
Let’s line up workers in order of their tax burden. The annual salary of the median worker is about 34 million won (KRW), and their annual income tax is approximately 370,000 won (KRW). This means a worker earning about 2.8 million won (KRW) per month pays just over 30,000 won (KRW) in taxes each month. That’s about 10,000 won (KRW) for every 100,000 won (KRW) earned. This amount is roughly half of their mobile phone bill. In contrast, the insurance premiums they pay for national pension and health insurance exceed this amount by more than seven times. In this worker's pay stub, income tax is a minor item.
Expanding the scope yields a similar picture. Among ten workers, six pay less in annual income tax than their mobile phone bills. Seven pay less than a smoker's tax on a pack of cigarettes per day. Three do not pay any tax at all. Even among those who do pay taxes, the median burden is about 100,000 won (KRW) per month. The commonly cited figure of '3.09 million won (KRW) per person' is an average created by the top 10% paying over 70% of total taxes, which is far from what the average worker actually pays. Using this average to argue that the tax burden on workers is heavy starts the discussion off on the wrong foot.
International comparisons further highlight the low level of income tax in South Korea. The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) annually compares the percentage of income tax paid by single workers earning the average wage. Last year, South Korea's rate was 7.1%, while the average among member countries was 15.5%. This is less than half. Moreover, this comparison is based on average wages, which are significantly higher than the annual salaries of median-income workers. This means that the actual income tax burden for median-income workers is much lower than 7.1%. Even Japan, which has a low income tax rate, sees a much larger burden when social insurance premiums are included. If we were to tax at the OECD average level, income tax would exceed double the current amount. With an aging population rapidly increasing the need for spending and corporate tax fluctuating with the semiconductor market, reducing stable tax sources would leave welfare reliant on debt. The path for income tax should not be reduction but rather gradual normalization.
Given that the burden level is so low, the prescriptions currently being discussed need to be reconsidered. Increasing deductions and non-taxable amounts primarily benefits higher-income individuals. Deductions are of no use to those who do not pay taxes. When one dependent is added, the tax for the lowest tax bracket worker decreases by 100,000 won (KRW), while the tax for the highest bracket worker decreases by 740,000 won (KRW). Proposals to raise the non-taxable limit for meal allowances are no different. While the distribution of tax credit benefits is less skewed, it still does not help those who owe little tax. In this context, introducing an inflation linkage system is premature as it would solidify the low burden. It would not be too late to implement it after the burden approaches the OECD average. Proposals to simply widen the lower tax brackets do not solve the issue either. The 6% tax rate is not exclusive to low-income earners; even someone earning 100 million won (KRW) pays only 6% on the first 14 million won (KRW) of their taxable income. This low initial tax rate contributes to our low income tax burden. Widening this bracket would also reduce taxes for high-income earners. This is why the government is cautious about adjusting tax brackets.
What actually reduces disposable income for salaried workers is something else. Since 2010, two-thirds of the increase in deductions from salaries has come from social insurance premiums, not income tax. The national pension premium rate will rise every year until 2033. Of course, premiums are money that returns as pensions and medical care. They cannot be viewed solely as a burden like taxes. Still, it is clear that it is not income tax that determines the actual take-home pay of workers. This is why we must consider premium increases when determining the pace of income tax. Additionally, housing costs, childcare, and education expenses must be factored in. The Salary Defense Force should focus on these areas.
The current tax system needs to establish a reasonable pace for tax increases. The issue is not merely that taxes are rising; it is problematic when they increase unknowingly without public policy being established. Until now, income tax has risen at a pace that no one has determined, and when dissatisfaction builds up, it has been repeatedly cut all at once. This was the case during the year-end settlement turmoil in 2015. With the addition of supplementary measures to the deduction reform, the number of workers not paying taxes increased from one in three to one in two, and it took a full decade to reverse this trend. Keeping tax brackets stagnant or cutting them all at once is not the answer. The government should regularly report how much the tax burden has increased across different income groups, and the National Assembly should publicly set the pace for these increases. This way, workers can understand why and how much their taxes are rising.
There are also other areas that need attention. For workers with low incomes who do not pay taxes, it is more appropriate to assist them through refundable tax credits rather than deductions. The government's direction to expand the Earned Income Tax Credit is valid in the long term. However, given that it has only recently been significantly expanded, there is a need to refrain from hasty further expansions. The basic deduction, which has been stuck at 1.5 million won (KRW) since 2009, should also be increased. At that time, deductions that are either ineffective or difficult to consider as necessary expenses should be reduced alongside this increase. The goal is not to increase deductions further but to rationally reorganize the deduction system.
The way to protect salaries is not to further cut already low taxes. It lies in reducing living costs and allowing taxes to approach a predictable pace at a normal level. It is time to set the pace for income tax rather than cut it.
* This article has been translated by AI.
Copyright ⓒ Aju Press All rights reserved.