Disagreements Over Labor Exceptions in Super-Wide Special Zones


Disagreements emerged among labor, management, and government regarding labor exceptions outlined in the Super-Wide Special Zone Act. While some in the labor sector and ruling party raised concerns about undermining labor laws and the potential for further expansion of exceptions, the business sector and the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy argued for regulatory relaxation to secure industrial competitiveness. The government is engaging in social dialogue to find common ground, but the labor sector's firm opposition to the exceptions suggests significant challenges ahead.

On November 18, the National Assembly Labor Forum and Democratic Party lawmaker Lee Yong-woo held a discussion titled "How Should We View the Labor Exception Clause in the Super-Wide Special Zone Act?" The forum included Employment and Labor Minister Kim Young-hoon, Korean Confederation of Trade Unions Chairman Kim Dong-myung, Emergency Response Committee Chairman Lee Jae-jin of the Korean Trade Union Confederation, and Ryu Ki-jung, Executive Vice President of the Korea Employers Federation.

Lee Hak-young, a representative of the National Assembly Labor Forum and a Democratic Party lawmaker, expressed concern over the potential expansion of labor exceptions to other regions and industries. He stated, "The way we grow is as important as the speed of growth. The urgency in industrial sites is real, and the worry that exceptions under the name of special zones could spread to other regions and industries is also true."

He added, "If different standards are applied to workers simply because they are in different regions, it contradicts the purpose of balanced development. Industrial competitiveness and labor rights are not opposing values but challenges that need to be designed together."

Shin Jang-sik, leader of the Rebuilding Korea Party, remarked, "I hope the Super-Wide Special Zone Act can serve as a catalyst for revitalizing regions," but questioned whether the extensive details covering not only labor but also education, healthcare, financial separation, and regional development could justify the rationale for labor exceptions.

The labor sector expressed discomfort with the ruling party's proposal of the special zone act containing labor exceptions while discussions between labor, management, and government are ongoing. They criticized the inclusion of exceptions that were not pursued even by previous administrations.

Kim Dong-myung, Chairman of the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions, stated, "While social dialogue is ongoing, everything that was previously agreed not to be included has been put into the bill. Isn’t that what we call a lie or deception? It is time to consider opposition to political forces and the regime that completely disregards the other side."

Lee Jae-jin, Chairman of the Emergency Response Committee of the Korean Trade Union Confederation, referred to the special zone act as a "super-large conglomerate privilege law," highlighting that it includes exceptions for regulatory relaxation that even military dictatorships did not implement.

Kim Seon-su, a former Supreme Court Justice who moderated the forum, expressed surprise at the bill, stating, "The content denies the history of labor law and undermines its fundamental purpose, ultimately dismantling labor law itself. Most of the provisions included are those that the business sector has persistently demanded and that the Yoon Suk Yeol administration attempted but failed to implement."

Conversely, the business sector argued that relaxing labor regulations is necessary to promote local investments. Kim Dong-hee, head of the Labor Standards Policy Team at the Korea Employers Federation, stated, "While it is said that everything the business sector has requested has been included, less than half of what we have been asking for has been addressed, which is unsatisfactory."

He expressed concern that, to create jobs in local areas, conditions and incentives for businesses must be established first, noting that special zone companies will inevitably operate with limited personnel, making it difficult to achieve sufficient outcomes within the 52-hour workweek regulation.

There were also differences in stance among government departments regarding labor exceptions. The Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy supported the introduction of exceptions, while the Ministry of Employment and Labor emphasized social dialogue.

Kim Jeong-gwan, Minister of Trade, Industry and Energy, argued that labor exceptions are necessary for future industrial competitiveness and job creation. Although he was absent from the forum due to a business trip to China, he stated in a congratulatory message, "Labor exceptions are essential to protect South Korea's industrial competitiveness," adding that rigid labor regulations that do not consider industry and job characteristics have limitations in responding to global technological competition.

He further stated, "Labor exceptions do not solely rely on the sacrifice of workers but ensure fair compensation and protect workers' health rights," emphasizing that industrial competitiveness and labor rights protection are not opposing but complementary values.

Kim Young-hoon, Minister of Employment and Labor, remarked, "The greater the differences in positions, the more we need to find solutions through dialogue," and assured that the government would engage in rigorous discussions based on concrete evidence and examples from the field without predetermined conclusions.

The Super-Wide Special Zone Act is a legislative measure supporting the government's three major mega-projects, designating special zones to foster regional strategic industries while providing regulatory exceptions and financial, fiscal, and tax support. The government and ruling party aim to pass the Super-Wide Special Zone Act by the end of the year, but discussions have stalled due to disagreements with the labor sector over labor exceptions, including exemptions from the 52-hour workweek.

Previously, the Democratic Party proposed two bills regarding the presence or absence of labor exceptions. Initially, they planned to review the two bills together to prepare a final proposal, but they are facing difficulties as the labor sector opposes the exception clauses.




* This article has been translated by AI.